Can You Name the Only MLB Team That Has Had a Cumulative Winning Record Since the Very First Game in Franchise History?

[u]edit[/u]:
Meaning there is only one team in MLB that has never had a single day in their franchise history in which their franchise's cumulative record wasn't above .500.

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

2ndtimeguy · 61-69, M

LA Dodgers and Atlanta/Milwaukee Braves , St Louis Cardinals, Cincinnati Reds and Washington Senators/ Minnesota Twins , Baltimore Orioles, Boston Red Sox so many teams were good in the 1900s but arent now but may have a total winning record Detroit comes to mind.

beckyromero · 36-40, F

@2ndtimeguy [quote]LA Dodgers and Atlanta/Milwaukee Braves , St Louis Cardinals, Cincinnati Reds and Washington Senators/ Minnesota Twins , Baltimore Orioles, Boston Red Sox so many teams were good in the 1900s but arent now but may have a total winning record Detroit comes to mind.[/quote]

None of the above have had a cumulative winning record ever since their first game.

Brooklyn (Dodgers franchise) lost their first game, to Washington, on May 1, 1884.
Boston (Braves franchise) dropped to .500 after playing their 2nd game in 1876.
St. Louis (Cardinals franchise in AA b/f moving to NL) were 3-4 after 7 games in their inaugural season in 1882.
Cincinnati (Reds franchise) lost their first game in their inaugural season in 1882 in the AA before moving to NL.
Washington (Twins franchise) won their first four games in franchise history in 1901. But were 5-6 by May 8th.
Milwaukee (Mil->StL->Baltimore Orioles franchise) lost their inaugural opening 14-13 to Detroit in 1901.
Boston lost their inaugural opening 10-6 to Baltimore in 1901.

Deroit started their inaugural season (1901) at 5-0 and never dropped to .500, finishing at 74-61. That's 13 games above .500. But an 8-1 loss to Boston on July 28th, 1902 put them at 31-45 on the season and a cumulative franchise record of 105-106.

So, no. Detroit isn't the correct answer, either.