This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Quizzical · 46-50, M
I'm convinced and now totally prepared to believe in magic, and an invisible all-knowing man who lives in the sky who grants wishes if I do exactly as he tells me to! 🙄
Quizzical · 46-50, M
@NewBecky Nothing this man could have said would convince me of the existence of Iehovah, or any other supernatural entity. I've read the bible from cover to cover, and you know what it's full of? Stories, myths, and legends from other non-Judaic religions that pre-date Christianity by hundreds of years.
Quizzical · 46-50, M
@NewBecky Let's take the flood story as an example, and Noah loading animals onto his ark.
In the Sumerian Epic of Gilgamesh a character called Utnapishtim is warned of an imminent flood to be unleashed by wrathful gods. He builds a vast circular-shaped boat, reinforced with tar and pitch, that carries his relatives, grains and animals. After enduring days of storms, Utnapishtim, like Noah in Genesis, releases a bird in search of dry land.
The Epic of Gilgamesh predates Christianity by about 2,500 years...
In the Sumerian Epic of Gilgamesh a character called Utnapishtim is warned of an imminent flood to be unleashed by wrathful gods. He builds a vast circular-shaped boat, reinforced with tar and pitch, that carries his relatives, grains and animals. After enduring days of storms, Utnapishtim, like Noah in Genesis, releases a bird in search of dry land.
The Epic of Gilgamesh predates Christianity by about 2,500 years...
Quizzical · 46-50, M
@NewBecky Sumerian writings predate the Torah too, they are widley regarded as the first civilisation and as I am led to understand the originators of written language.
My point is that when you look at ALL religious teachings rather than just the one you notice similarities between them, whether they be monotheistic or polytheistic religions. Religions that predate Christianity, telling the same stories, offering the same parables. So it's not great leap in logic to see that Christianity co-opted these stories to support it's own burgeoning faith system, as it also did with festivals at certain times of the year, such as the celebration of Eostre of the festival of Saturnalia.
So how can anything in the bible be true when the information contained within was plagiarised from other places?
My point is that when you look at ALL religious teachings rather than just the one you notice similarities between them, whether they be monotheistic or polytheistic religions. Religions that predate Christianity, telling the same stories, offering the same parables. So it's not great leap in logic to see that Christianity co-opted these stories to support it's own burgeoning faith system, as it also did with festivals at certain times of the year, such as the celebration of Eostre of the festival of Saturnalia.
So how can anything in the bible be true when the information contained within was plagiarised from other places?
NewBecky · 51-55, F
@Quizzical Perhaps it did not occur to you that, assuming the Bible IS correct... then all people would have come from Noah and his family. And so, all people from after Noah's time would have recorded the story of a great flood sent by (a) God. Of course! So all people share that in common from very early history serving only to confirm but not to disprove anything. But the predating argument is common. In the end, because of how it is employed, it becomes nothing but propaganda.
Quizzical · 46-50, M
@NewBecky It's common because it's correct...
And people can't possibly have come from Noah and his family, you need to have at the very least 80 men and 80 women breeding together to ensure genetic diversity amongst humans, otherwise you end up with deleterious mutations over time.
And people can't possibly have come from Noah and his family, you need to have at the very least 80 men and 80 women breeding together to ensure genetic diversity amongst humans, otherwise you end up with deleterious mutations over time.
NewBecky · 51-55, F
@Quizzical The first word of the Bible tells the entire story of the Bible,,, that Christ would die on the cross. Bar = Son Alef = Father or God as silent letter Shin = Destroy ( A picture of jagged rocks) Yod = Hand Tov or Tav... I forget but the picture is a "Mark" or a T ... thousands of years before the cross was ever used for execution.
Quizzical · 46-50, M
@NewBecky Of course it's an issue, lol.
Dogs didn't just spring into existence with 'the first dog' and then change from there... They evolved from a type of wolf and changed over time, in some cases naturally, and in others through selective breeding.
You stick to religion and I'll stick to science. I know which I have more trust in.
Dogs didn't just spring into existence with 'the first dog' and then change from there... They evolved from a type of wolf and changed over time, in some cases naturally, and in others through selective breeding.
You stick to religion and I'll stick to science. I know which I have more trust in.
NewBecky · 51-55, F
@Quizzical You should know that the scientific method requires observation. What you propose might be a theory but it is not seen in the universe today. Rather, Tureks position that the universe is and has been expanding IS supported by the scientific method. It is observed.
You present a theory with no scientific evidence. Rather than follow your theory that would require greater faith than following Frank Tureks observations... and the great minds that he quotes.... I'll stick with Surge for now... I don't have enough faith to be an atheist.
You present a theory with no scientific evidence. Rather than follow your theory that would require greater faith than following Frank Tureks observations... and the great minds that he quotes.... I'll stick with Surge for now... I don't have enough faith to be an atheist.