Update
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

What the Bible says about astrology

A response to the Skeptic's Annotated Bible (SAB) What The Bible Says About Astrology

On What the Bible Says about Astrology the Skeptic's Annotated Bible (SAB), using the King James Version (KJV) has come to the erroneous conclusion that there is some contradiction. They have come to this conclusion due, not to any discrepancy in the Bible but rather a confusion of what the Bible is actually saying regarding the sun and moon being a sign of the seasons, of the stars being used in a figurative sense, etc.

An attempt to understand more carefully what the Bible teaches about such things would easily clear up any confusion the earnest Bible student may have regarding astrology. Part of this educational process would logically include a brief examination of the history of astrology.

As far back as 1800 BCE star catalogs were kept in Mesopotamia, they were instrumental to the Babylonians for predicting astronomical events such as lunar eclipses, marking the movement of planets and the rising and setting of constellations. Ancient people such as the Assyrians, Chinese, Egyptians, Greeks, Native Americans, Romans and others watched the sky and kept records of astronomical events. They were thus able to make calendars and plan yearly events such as planting and harvesting of crops.

To a superstitious people astronomy became astrology when they began to think that since the signs of the sun, moon and stars allowed them to predict the seasons, the ebb and flow of the tide, the flood of the Nile followed by the appearance of Sirius, then perhaps they could predict one's future or fortune.

The Babylonians thought of the stars as the heavenly abode of the gods. Bright stars, eclipses, and comets were thought to bring wrath upon the earth from the gods. Wars were fought and kings looked to their astrologers to ascertain the future.

The form of astrology that we know today comes from the Greeks. In the second century CE Greek astronomer Claudius Ptolemy from Alexandria, Egypt compiled a four-book astrological record entitled Tetrabiblos. This has served as a basic text for what is today called natal astrology, a means of predicting one's future by charting the position of the stars, sun, moon and planets on the date of one's birth.

In the 13th century the Zohar or Sefar ho-zohar (Hebrew Book of Splendor) read: "On the firmament which envelops the universe, we see many figures formed by the stars and planets. They reveal hidden things and profound mysteries. Similarly, upon our skin which encircles the human being there exist forms and traits that are the stars of our bodies." This work inspired the reading of the face and palm for predicting the future.

By the 14th and 15th centuries astrology had gained a great deal of respect in the West. Universities were teaching it as a discipline which required skills in language and mathematics. Astrologers were thought of as scholars. It had a tremendous influence on human affairs, from building, wars, travel, business, in the lives of noblemen and the royal court. The writings of William Shakespeare are full of references to the astrological influences on human affairs.

In Strasbourg in 1531 Johannes Indagine wrote a book on the subject which quoted Jesus at Matthew 6:22 and concluded that large, bright, and round eyes indicated integrity and good health but sunken and small eyes were signs of envy, suspicion and malice. Just two years later Bartolommeo Coclé, in his book Compendium of Physiognomy, claimed that large and round eyes were an indication that a person was fickle and lazy.

Chiromancers (palm readers) believed that the hands reflected the forces from above and they searched the Bible for references to that effect. Misapplying Bible verses like Job 37:7 and Proverbs 3:16.

Though the work of astronomers like Copernicus, Galileo and Kepler, who have clearly demonstrated the unscientific reasoning behind astrologers from the past - that the planet Earth is not the center of the universe, that some stars that appear in a constellation are not bound to a specific group, that planets are lifeless rock masses or gases, as well as the discovery with the telescope of planets not known to exist in ancient times such as Uranus, and Neptune which would have influenced the charts we still use today, many people remain enchanted by astrology.

Genetics tells us that our traits are formed upon conception, not nine months later at birth, and we see that the sun is about one month behind what it was 2,000 years ago when the charts we use today were drawn up. That would mean that a Cancer (highly sensitive, moody and reserved) would actually be a Gemini (communicative, witty and chatty.)

Edit: the last paragraph of this article was removed as it was included by mistake. It was supposed to be the first paragraph of a follow up entitled Does the Bible Condemn Astrology

https://similarworlds.com/astrology/4673495-Does-the-Bible-condemn-astrology-A-Response-To-Does-The
revenant · F
Astrology was the astronomy of the time.
There is more than the Sun and the Moon being taken into consideration though. Astrology was also in use to predict emperors, falls of aristocracies, natural disasters and so on.
revenant · F
@BlueSkyKing If you even read what I wrote...........................................................🙄
@revenant If it’s not science, it’s superstition. Your emperor has no clothes.
revenant · F
@BlueSkyKing That is what you are displaying. Superstition is believing something without evidence.

And honestly I really could not care what you do believe or not. It does not affect my life in the least.
It was all astrology and not astronomy until Galileo turned his telescope to the sky. Even he was using astrology to make money and used the moons of Jupiter in his charts of his benefactor.

But giving credit when due, the ancient astrology observers did a Herculean job of precision mapping the naked eye planets. The bottom line is that there are many types of astrology and none mesh with each other. It’s divination of random events. Individual points of view and an assumed psychic ability.

The primary purpose of astrology was predicting the future. The "modern" current stereotyping is about programming personalities, using mythology based stereotyping. Probably because of competition of faster fortune telling. Back in the 19th century, reading bumps on the skull was more popular.

In the Bible astrology was an abomination. Astrologers were mocked in the book of Daniel.
Well written and very interesting.
May I have your permission to copy it?
To offer to people interested in this topic. I think it could provoke some great conversations.
I would not post it anywhere on line, nor try to publish it - and I would tell people it was written by Theoretic Skeptic - or your real name if you prefered.
BibleData · M
@hartfire [quote]What is your background?[/quote]

Background? I'm just this guy, ya know?

Was raised an unbeliever and became a believer. I loath and never have belonged to any organized religion.
@BibleData I was raised by an atheist and an agnostic.
Explored various beliefs but never became a believer.
Think skepticism can be very healthy - if not taken to the extreme of an automatic response to everything and everyone.
Love scientific method and the processes by which science makes its discoveries.
Very much like the Buddhist take on awareness and ethics,
and some aspects of Lao Tzu's Taoist thinking.
BibleData · M
@hartfire [quote]Think skepticism can be very healthy - if not taken to the extreme of an automatic response to everything and everyone.
Love scientific method and the processes by which science makes its discoveries.[/quote]

Exactly. I would stress the importance in acknowledgement that the scientific processes are infallible and corruptible.

[quote]Very much like the Buddhist take on awareness and ethics,
and some aspects of Lao Tzu's Taoist thinking.[/quote]

Me too, so long as they don't become overly complicated and metaphysical respectively. I especially like the 4 Noble Truths and letting go.

https://semmelweisreflex.com/library/4nt/4nt.php
originnone · 61-69, M
Do you really think anyone will read this?
BibleData · M
@originnone If I saw a post that big that I wasn't interested in I wouldn't read it. If I was interested in the subject I would read it.

Make sense?
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Peaceandnamaste · 26-30, F
@BlueSkyKing And don't forget Trumpism and Gunism.
BibleData · M
@Peaceandnamaste You're politicizing astrology and "Abrahamism"?
Peaceandnamaste · 26-30, F
@BibleData Astrology is too deterministic.

 
Post Comment