She did technically chop off some fingers but returned them so for me, it's the thought that counts.

Playing Withering Rooms on Steam. I have to make a choice to be a friend or not to someone who chopped off all her friend's fingers, she returned them the next day and her friends were so mad that they chained her to a wall and she's been there ever since. I am going in blind because I don't want to ruin anything I just decided that she needed a friend. I can't imagine that it's any fun being chained to a wall with no company.