What do you think?

Poll - Total Votes: 5

Yes, evil.

No, not evil

You can only vote on one answer.

Mark Twain believed humans are the only truly evil creatures on this planet because of our sense of right and wrong. Nothing a tiger does is immoral because it has no moral sense. Our moral sense curses us with the ability to choose evil, a trait wholly unique to humanity. What do you think? Are humans the only evil creature?

Top | Newest First | Oldest First

Nika2002 · 22-25, F

Ever watch a cat needlessly torture a mouse for hours?

View 1 more replies »

Nika2002 · 22-25, F

@Lonelyheart If, as Twain suggests our judgment is all that matters- then the cat is evil.

Lonelyheart · 26-30, M

@Nika2002 I think that would be closer to personification of the cat. The cat doesn’t view it as wrong but we do so we associate the cat with wrong

RadiantRuby

@Lonelyheart your a smart pants Mr!

Abstraction · 61-69, M

If so - holding the logic - it makes us the only truly good creature, as well.

JavaJim · 61-69, M

Humans are not the only evil creatures. There are numerous studies showing animals do "evil" behavior (lie, steal, murder their own kind, etc), and if that's too difficult to look for then go on YouTube and look up "animals are jerks"

RadiantRuby

@JavaJim lol that's very bizare

Ladyred · 46-50, F

I think it's a bit more complex than that. My question would be does an animal have a soul? Any animal, wild or domesticated?

View 1 more replies »

Ladyred · 46-50, F

@Lonelyheart ahhh, so in your estimation soul or no soul an animal is justified in their behavior...Can an animal feel emotional pain, or memories? Or is it merely instinct of survival?

Lonelyheart · 26-30, M

@Ladyred from what I have seen animals have emotions and memories. They would have to if you were to train an animal. But of course it does depend on the animal. An animal with higher level thinking like apes can have emotions and memories while an ant or lower thinking animal would mostly act on instinct.

Ladyred · 46-50, F

@Lonelyheart So the question is are human beings the only soul-bearing creature capable of evil? And you are speaking morals..if animals have no morals than they cannot ultimately be responsible for their actions. While human beings with the option of morals are intrinsically evil, or can choose to be. While an animal, without morals cannot choose?

RadiantRuby

I think some other animals are also conscious. But they just can't communicate! Some animals take revenge if you piss them off, isn't that considered evil?

Lonelyheart · 26-30, M

@RadiantRuby some animals will seek revenge to make sure you don’t piss them off again (defensive)

This comment is hidden. Show Comment

Add a comment...