Should I try my chances with this possible tinder catfish or just leave it alone?

🤷🏻 why not

Try it

Leave it. If it's too good to be true it always is. But go ahead and give her your email because she will ask for it soon enough.

Flip a coin

Leaving it means no gain and no loss. Taking chances means either gain or loss. Are you comfortable with where you're at now? in that case, leave it. If not, try it.