This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Northwest · M
People have been committing murder, starting wars, and persecution, in the name of religion. All religions. Tomorrow evening, a man is going to be executed in Texas, for having participated in a racially motivated murder. The victim's daughter and sisters are calling on Texas to stop the execution, citing their Christian beliefs, but Texas, citing the same set of beliefs, insists that he must be put to death.
It's about the people, not the religion.
It's about the people, not the religion.
Northwest · M
@Carazaa If you mean John 13:35, then it's something that's been abused, by those who say that
It only refers to Jesus's people, not everyone else. Though, I believe his overall message was clear "peace not war and hate", without resorting to specific Bible verses.
By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you love one another
It only refers to Jesus's people, not everyone else. Though, I believe his overall message was clear "peace not war and hate", without resorting to specific Bible verses.
Carazaa · F
@NorthwestI would guess that if someone lied to you, or stole from you, you would not act loving to them? Jesus has told us to love our enemies, and pray for those who despitefully use us. He says everyone can love a loving person, but I tell you to love even your enemies. Do you do that?
Northwest · M
@Carazaa A wise person said "fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me".
There is a difference between forgiveness and enablement. Forgiveness is easy, but those who commit wrong, must make amends, otherwise, they're simply taking advantage, and will re-offend.
I don't believe in prayer, but I do believe that a discussion can convey the message.
Let's take politics as an example. I don't want to hate, or seek revenge against Trump, but I can't possibly stand aside, and let him destroy the world we live in. My activism is political, as in the ballot box, but I don't "love him", regardless.
There is a difference between forgiveness and enablement. Forgiveness is easy, but those who commit wrong, must make amends, otherwise, they're simply taking advantage, and will re-offend.
I don't believe in prayer, but I do believe that a discussion can convey the message.
Let's take politics as an example. I don't want to hate, or seek revenge against Trump, but I can't possibly stand aside, and let him destroy the world we live in. My activism is political, as in the ballot box, but I don't "love him", regardless.
Northwest · M
@Carazaa
Some of the people fleeing their countries, are not poor, but victims of the crimes of our Western political games, and it is our moral responsibility to accommodate them. I don't need a God to tell me that this is the right thing to do.
I don't need a God to tell me that hurting, abusing, or using people is not morally acceptable.
I don't need a God to tell me that my good fortune, is not self-made, but rather a by product of the work done by all those who came before me, or those who are helping me achieve it, even if they are employees.
Some things are "universal" and not connected to religion. You choose to channel them through religion, and I am not faulting you for that. I choose a universal moral compass, for a variety of reasons.
I am a Christian who believe in helping poor people fleeing their countries because of poverty or any other reason. God wants us to help them I believe. So it appears that you and I have similar believes in some respect
Some of the people fleeing their countries, are not poor, but victims of the crimes of our Western political games, and it is our moral responsibility to accommodate them. I don't need a God to tell me that this is the right thing to do.
I don't need a God to tell me that hurting, abusing, or using people is not morally acceptable.
I don't need a God to tell me that my good fortune, is not self-made, but rather a by product of the work done by all those who came before me, or those who are helping me achieve it, even if they are employees.
Some things are "universal" and not connected to religion. You choose to channel them through religion, and I am not faulting you for that. I choose a universal moral compass, for a variety of reasons.
Northwest · M
@Carazaa I said "amends", which does not mean the same thing as "vengeance". If I am commit a wrong, and I am forgiven for it, then it means absolutely nothing, unless I make amends, in at least an attempt to make up for it.
Retaliation is not love.
If God is vengeance, then God is not love.
Retaliation is not love.
If God is vengeance, then God is not love.
Carazaa · F
@Northwest Yes God is loving but He has a right to take out vengeance on those who oppose him. He has no obligation towards us when we are hateful. And even those who hated him Jesus died for even them, so they can be forgiven for all their sins. He took all their sins on His shoulders. Would you do that for someone who hates you?
Northwest · M
@Carazaa I use a very simple formula.
Love does not equal vengeance
Vengeance means not forgiving one's enemies
Jesus said forgive one's enemies, regardless
Therefore Jesus does not condone, or use, vengeance
If God uses vengeance, then God does not believe in forgiving one's enemy
There's a clear contradiction here, right? Or is that everything would be cool, only if people are obedient? Seems like masters used to treat slaves, doesn't it?
Love does not equal vengeance
Vengeance means not forgiving one's enemies
Jesus said forgive one's enemies, regardless
Therefore Jesus does not condone, or use, vengeance
If God uses vengeance, then God does not believe in forgiving one's enemy
There's a clear contradiction here, right? Or is that everything would be cool, only if people are obedient? Seems like masters used to treat slaves, doesn't it?
Carazaa · F
@Northwest No it is not a contradiction. Jesus IS Almighty God. He wants us to be loving. He will come one day as a lion and take vengeance on those who have hurt the world he says. There is not a contradiction here, just because we have a hard time understanding God. Jesus says
"How can you escape if you neglect such a great salvation"
"How can you escape if you neglect such a great salvation"