I Am Not Confident In Myself

You need to reinterpret some of your self-image:

Ugly = unique, interesting looking.

No fashion sense = an original, unconventional kinda guy

Trying hard to be funny = witty, amusing

Non-athletic = interesting and poetic

Can't drive = sensitive to the environment, appreciates walking, supports public transportation

Weird = poetic, avant-garde, not a mindless conformist

Watches anime = has great taste in visual art

Antisocial = Your own man, not dependent on the opinion of others, a rugged individual!

Only good at math = A super brain, smarter than most..."Mathematics is the language of the universe."

You've missed one thing to mention...
Other guys: ugly soul
Me: Beautiful soul

Question? With mathematics expertise, have you ever looked into numerology? If you open your mind and put that together who knows, you might search for the tools you are looking for. Just thought I'd mention as it relates to greenmountanigals comment "mathematics is the language of the universe". We all have individual gifts, and other cool hidden traits of who we are, fear just gets in our way.

Start working out all it takes is an hour a day

Lol except for the fact that I don't have abs, non-athletic, hates the gym, mostly anti-social but yeah parties are cool with drugs in it and... I watch anime. So basically you just need one thing, confidence. 😂

She conned you into teaching her some math? That fuckin bitch.