Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

How would you program a self-driving car?

This website presents you with several life-and-death decisions that a self-driving car would have to make in the event of brake failure. For example, you would choose between mowing down pedestrians in a crosswalk, killing all of them, or swerving into a wall and killing the car's passengers. Various scenarios are presented, involving more or fewer people, men vs. women, young vs. old, humans vs. animals, athletic vs. overweight people, pedestrians crossing with the "walk" signal vs. crossing with "don't walk," and professions (doctors, criminals, or homeless). It's a more complex version of the Trolley Problem.

It also illuminates inherent biases. I found that I made decisions based on the following.

Since being a passenger in a vehicle is inherently more dangerous than being a pedestrian, I tended to prioritze pedestrians over passengers.

I prioritized people who followed the law (crossing with the "walk" signal) over people who did not follow the law.

I prioritized humans over animals.

I prioritized saving more people over saving fewer.

Age, profession, gender, and physical fitness level were irrelevant.

All else being equal, I favored driving straight ahead over swerving.

https://www.moralmachine.net/
Top | New | Old
Thinkerbell · 41-45, F
I would favor a car with emergency brakes.
Years ago, MIT had a similar Morality Engine Test! This is similar.
I'd probably never get that far, as I'd only help if math was permitted, and if we agreed to minimize casualties and losses BEFORE choosing what kind of machine to travel in.
Of course there's nothing like a JOB for people who use that approach! There's only a BLACKLIST and a big huge majority working together to exclude us!
Like whatever you blockade Cuba and the point to Cuba and go "See, socialism makers you poor!".
JSul3 · 70-79
That's the issue with self driving autos.
Humans make moral decisions....self driving autos should never be allowed to make.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
MethDozer · M
I'd just program the stupid thing to self destruct. Self driving vehicles have no place on public roads. You want self driving? Put it on rails

 
Post Comment