This post may contain Mildly Adult content.
Mildly AdultAsking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Can you separate art from the artist ?

That is to say, can you appreciate art for its own sake, even if its artist is revealed to be despicable personally, for example, someone who was an excellent musician, actor ot producer but committed sexual assault, cheated on partners, was openly anti-Semitic or racist ?

If some ills are more acceptable to you than others, where do you draw the line ?
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Harmonium1923 · 51-55, M
I've been pondering this all day, and it's a tough question. If the artist's hatred or bias is reflected directly in their work, then that's clearly a problem. Otherwise it depends a bit more on the context, the nature of the issue, the nature and quality of the work, etc. A few examples, considering only the area of anti-Semitism:

Mel Gibson: I don't see any reason to watch his films given his prolonged an unapologetic anti-Semitism (some of which comes through in his work) and misogyny. If he were as good a film director as Alfred Hitchcock, that might be another story.

Sally Rooney: I was troubled by her refusal to have her books translated into Hebrew as a protest against Israel. The fact that she didn't have concerns about Saudi Arabia, China, or any number of other countries suggests to me that the issue goes beyond political protest. I'm a big reader and bookstore browser, but I've chosen not to purchase or read her work. There are a lot of other good books in the world. But again, if she were as good as George Eliot, I might feel otherwise.

Kanye: He's batshit crazy and I'll have nothing to do with him.

Classic writers: Charles Dickens, George Eliot, Anthony Trollope, TS Eliot and Ezra Pound all had aspects of either their work or their other writings that could fairly be called anti-Semitic. For some, like Dickens and Eliot, they had later recognition of that fact and were apologetic in later works. For others, not so much. I love and read all of these writers except Pound.