Freedom of speech?

Why is that when you criticize Christianity, Islam, Hinduism etc (religion, not individuals). It's a matter of freedom of speech but when you question Judaism and Zionism, it becomes a matter of anti-semitism only? Why not freedom of speech applies in that subject?

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

SW-User

A good question. Any time I criticise Israel and their incredibly aggressive policies (before some fool replies to this, no I am not a supporter of Hamas) the response is the same "You're an anti semite!".

When did criticising someone's behaviour become equal to hating them as a person or hating them because of their religion?

Challenger1 · M

I don't think it should be. Even though I would generally defend Israel I will not accuse you of being anti semite. Not unless you have clearly demonstrated that you are.

MorningStar · 31-35, M

Every group is so biased. I'm against human rights violation committed by anyone whether be christians, muslims, hindus, jews, (i'm a muslim too). Now you can blame it on individuals only but the popular opinion doesn't work that way lol.

SW-User

@MarsSword: Well that is fair. I do try to only criticise people based on their actions. I have nothing against Jews, Muslims, Christians or any group as a whole.

Challenger1 · M

@Noctus: You can blame it on individuals. But when there is a huge statistical disproportion of crimes committed by one group over another group within a given time period then there is cause for concern that the individuals might be influenced by something that is not a good influence. You know, kind of like the correlation between cigarettes and lung cancer.

MorningStar · 31-35, M

@MarsSword: Sure, but that doesn't happen with Zionism, I guess because they know how to run the game better.

Challenger1 · M

@Noctus: Or there isn't large scale Zionist sanctioned murders being committed on the regular.

What would be the disproportionate number of crimes committed by Zionists?