I Couldn't Resist Responding: What If Japan Invaded Hawaii in 1941?
[media=https://youtu.be/CfgZXlbwElg]
Watch the video and then read my response in the comments there (I've re-posted it below):
Not even Rear Admiral Tamon Yamaguchi had such severe victory disease as sending virtually the entire IJN eastward on December 7th, 1941 and hoping they wouldn't be discovered by a sub, ship or aircraft. Yamaguchi's own proposal to invade Oahu was to be only AFTER the invasion and occupation of the island of Midway, Johnston, and Palmyra, as well as of the big island of Hawai'i itself.
Furthermore, it borders on incredulity to think that Admiral "Bull" Halsey commanding Task Force 8 would attempt to launch a counter-attack with Enterprise and its three heavy cruisers against the bulk of the Japanese fleet. Admiral Kimmel would have ordered Halsey to head to Pago Pago.
Rear Admiral John H. Newton with Task Force 12 (USS Lexington, three heavy cruisers and five destroyers) would have similarly been ordered to stay away, most likely detaching three destroyers back to Midway and head at full speed to San Francisco with the Lex, the cruisers and two destroyers (refueling them at sea) and arriving under the Golden Gate on December 11 or 12th.
Meanwhile, Task Group 15.5, a convoy with 4,600 troops and supplies and escorted by the heavy cruiser Pensacola that was heading to the Philippines would be immediately ordered to turn around (as it actually was) and head to Fiji (as it actually was).
The carrier Saratoga was already on the west coast. By January she would be joined by the fast battleships Washington and North Carolina, their trial runs in the Gulf of Mexico and the Atlantic, respectively, cut short. They were both having propeller vibration issues but in this type of an emergency they would have slowed to 22 kts and the battleships Idaho, New Mexico and Colorado would have joined them in San Diego.
The carrier Yorktown was ordered to the Pacific, transiting through the Panama Canal and arriving in San Diego in late December. The heavy cruiser Louisville would join her in January.
There was one more powerful battleship on the West Coast that could have joined this powerful fleet being assembled: HMS Warspite was at the Puget Sound Naval Shipyard in Bremerton, Washington undergoing repairs and a refit that was completed in late December 1941. But instead of making a long journey down the west coast, across the Pacific and arriving in Sydney in late February 1942, before joining Admiral Somerville's Eastern Fleet a month later in Trincomalee, Ceylon, the British Admiralty loans HMS Warspite to the Americans.
The Pacific Fleet would now have three carriers, two fast battleships, four additional battleships and four heavy cruisers on the U.S. west coast and Enterprise and three heavy cruisers in American Samoa.
Meanwhile, since the IJN has stripped the eastern Pacific of nearly all available troop transports for its Hawai'i invasion (along with those landing craft that really didn't even exist), Rear Admiral Tom Phillips, commanding Force Z, has no reason to steam into danger with the battleship HMS Prince of Wales and battle cruiser HMS Repulse. They, along with the heavy cruiser HMS Exeter, remain at Singapore.
By mid-January 1942, the carrier HMS Indomitable arrives, followed by Vice Admiral James Somerville and the carrier HMS Formidable. Instead of crossing the North Atlantic heading towards Britain (where she collided with HMS Formidable, delaying her arrival to the Eastern Fleet), the carrier HMS Illustrious heads across the South Atlantic with Indomitable.
The British Eastern Fleet also has the heavy cruisers Cornwall and Dorsetshire. The slow and aging carrier Hermes and four old Revenge-class battleships remain at and near Colombo, Ceylon.
In return for the British loaning the Americans the battleship Warspite, the heavy cruiser Houston leaves the Philippines and is put under British command, along with the Australia heavy cruisers HMAS Australia and HMAS Canberra.
And with the bulk of the IJN blockading Hawai'i and launching smaller invasions of Midway and Wake Island, the British have no need to play defense. Somerville, with three carriers at his disposal along with Wales and Repulse, pounds Japanese airfields and severs Japan's oil lifeline. Meanwhile, the Philippines are untouched by a Japanese invasion and Gen. MacArthur still has at least half of the 5th Air Force to strike at Japanese air bases in Formosa and turns the Philippines into an unsinkable aircraft carrier. Admiral Thomas Hart has nearly 30 submarines at his disposal and they can now spend the vast majority of their time on patrol instead of in transit.
It wouldn't be long before U.S. submarines are torpedoing oil tankers and supply ships in view of the Japanese home islands and Somerville's surface fleet and carriers might even swing into Manila harbor once Singapore is safely secured.
Before the Kidō Butai had ever left Hitokappu Bay and steamed eastward, Admiral Chūichi Nagumo had warned against bypassing the Philippines, saying the U.S. military presence there was "a pistol aimed at Japan's heart." Now, as his ships lacked the oil and supplies to fight either a battle with the Americans to the East or the British to the West his worst fears were coming to fruition.
Watch the video and then read my response in the comments there (I've re-posted it below):
Not even Rear Admiral Tamon Yamaguchi had such severe victory disease as sending virtually the entire IJN eastward on December 7th, 1941 and hoping they wouldn't be discovered by a sub, ship or aircraft. Yamaguchi's own proposal to invade Oahu was to be only AFTER the invasion and occupation of the island of Midway, Johnston, and Palmyra, as well as of the big island of Hawai'i itself.
Furthermore, it borders on incredulity to think that Admiral "Bull" Halsey commanding Task Force 8 would attempt to launch a counter-attack with Enterprise and its three heavy cruisers against the bulk of the Japanese fleet. Admiral Kimmel would have ordered Halsey to head to Pago Pago.
Rear Admiral John H. Newton with Task Force 12 (USS Lexington, three heavy cruisers and five destroyers) would have similarly been ordered to stay away, most likely detaching three destroyers back to Midway and head at full speed to San Francisco with the Lex, the cruisers and two destroyers (refueling them at sea) and arriving under the Golden Gate on December 11 or 12th.
Meanwhile, Task Group 15.5, a convoy with 4,600 troops and supplies and escorted by the heavy cruiser Pensacola that was heading to the Philippines would be immediately ordered to turn around (as it actually was) and head to Fiji (as it actually was).
The carrier Saratoga was already on the west coast. By January she would be joined by the fast battleships Washington and North Carolina, their trial runs in the Gulf of Mexico and the Atlantic, respectively, cut short. They were both having propeller vibration issues but in this type of an emergency they would have slowed to 22 kts and the battleships Idaho, New Mexico and Colorado would have joined them in San Diego.
The carrier Yorktown was ordered to the Pacific, transiting through the Panama Canal and arriving in San Diego in late December. The heavy cruiser Louisville would join her in January.
There was one more powerful battleship on the West Coast that could have joined this powerful fleet being assembled: HMS Warspite was at the Puget Sound Naval Shipyard in Bremerton, Washington undergoing repairs and a refit that was completed in late December 1941. But instead of making a long journey down the west coast, across the Pacific and arriving in Sydney in late February 1942, before joining Admiral Somerville's Eastern Fleet a month later in Trincomalee, Ceylon, the British Admiralty loans HMS Warspite to the Americans.
The Pacific Fleet would now have three carriers, two fast battleships, four additional battleships and four heavy cruisers on the U.S. west coast and Enterprise and three heavy cruisers in American Samoa.
Meanwhile, since the IJN has stripped the eastern Pacific of nearly all available troop transports for its Hawai'i invasion (along with those landing craft that really didn't even exist), Rear Admiral Tom Phillips, commanding Force Z, has no reason to steam into danger with the battleship HMS Prince of Wales and battle cruiser HMS Repulse. They, along with the heavy cruiser HMS Exeter, remain at Singapore.
By mid-January 1942, the carrier HMS Indomitable arrives, followed by Vice Admiral James Somerville and the carrier HMS Formidable. Instead of crossing the North Atlantic heading towards Britain (where she collided with HMS Formidable, delaying her arrival to the Eastern Fleet), the carrier HMS Illustrious heads across the South Atlantic with Indomitable.
The British Eastern Fleet also has the heavy cruisers Cornwall and Dorsetshire. The slow and aging carrier Hermes and four old Revenge-class battleships remain at and near Colombo, Ceylon.
In return for the British loaning the Americans the battleship Warspite, the heavy cruiser Houston leaves the Philippines and is put under British command, along with the Australia heavy cruisers HMAS Australia and HMAS Canberra.
And with the bulk of the IJN blockading Hawai'i and launching smaller invasions of Midway and Wake Island, the British have no need to play defense. Somerville, with three carriers at his disposal along with Wales and Repulse, pounds Japanese airfields and severs Japan's oil lifeline. Meanwhile, the Philippines are untouched by a Japanese invasion and Gen. MacArthur still has at least half of the 5th Air Force to strike at Japanese air bases in Formosa and turns the Philippines into an unsinkable aircraft carrier. Admiral Thomas Hart has nearly 30 submarines at his disposal and they can now spend the vast majority of their time on patrol instead of in transit.
It wouldn't be long before U.S. submarines are torpedoing oil tankers and supply ships in view of the Japanese home islands and Somerville's surface fleet and carriers might even swing into Manila harbor once Singapore is safely secured.
Before the Kidō Butai had ever left Hitokappu Bay and steamed eastward, Admiral Chūichi Nagumo had warned against bypassing the Philippines, saying the U.S. military presence there was "a pistol aimed at Japan's heart." Now, as his ships lacked the oil and supplies to fight either a battle with the Americans to the East or the British to the West his worst fears were coming to fruition.


