Positive
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

This concept is Marxist. You wouldn't think so, but the definition fits.

Notice, I'm not saying Socialist. I'm saying Marxist because the concept is a mirror image of that Marx line in the Gotha Programme ("From each according to his abilities to each according to his needs." )

The concept is insurance. ALL insurance.
You might have heard all kinds of definitions of it, but there is only ONE: A pot of money a large number of people contribute to, with the idea that some people take from it for an unexpected illness or death.
(That is the ONLY correct definition of insurance. I used to be licensed to sell health and life in Florida and had to pass the state exam. I REALLY didn't know the correct definition was that.)
From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs.

I didn't say Socialist because Socialism is where government OWNS all the means of production in a country. That is the proper definition.
(No, it's not government spending. You can't say paying taxes to maintain roads or pay cop salaries is Socialism.)

Notice, I'm not condemning the concept. Not saying if it is right or wrong, good or evil. Insurance is a part of our life.

(By the way, Social Security is NOT an insurance program, as much as recipients would give you a black eye if you suggest it is. According to the original administrators of Social Security, they argued before the Supreme Court that Social Security was a WELFARE program that is financed by government's ability to tax the population. If anything, Social Security as a financial tool would most likely resemble a life annuity in the private sector. I used to sell those as well. You have to be life licensed to sell them if they come from a life insurance company.)

Again, this isn't a political debate. This is a fact, according to the material. And again, I'm not knocking it. Just giving the right definition.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
Okay I'm going to break down some terms here for you because I think your political definitions are coming from personal inference.

Marxism is a way of thinking about things and particularly capitalism. It understands capitalism as a class conflict and applies concepts such as historical materialism and dialectical reasoning to the way society and economy works so you can understand why things they way they are.

Socialism is a very very broad umbrella term for an array of political ideologies and movements that places the "social question" at the forefront of how you order a society. It arose in the early 19th century as a response to the liberal movement.

You can be an almost entirely command economy and have some capitalist policies. Or you can be an entirely capitalist society and have socialist policies.

Or you can be a form of socialist that doesn't want the government to own anything at all. Libertarian socialism was the first kind of libertarianism.

Anyways that's long way of saying insurance is not Marxist. It's a private for-profit industry and a mechanism of capitalism.
Reason10 · 70-79, M
@CountScrofula @CountScrofula
Okay I'm going to break down some terms here for you because I think your political definitions are coming from personal inference.
You would be wrong. My definitions come from ECONOMICS textbooks.

Marxism is a way of thinking about things and particularly capitalism. It understands capitalism as a class conflict and applies concepts such as historical materialism and dialectical reasoning to the way society and economy works so you can understand why things they way they are.

If you want the Marxist way of thinking about things, it's very simple: Abolition of private property, and abolition of the family and abolition of countries and nationality.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1848/communist-manifesto/ch02.htm

The concept of "libertarian socialism" is an oxymoron. The two concepts are about as opposite as it gets.