Why are Indians protesting? The government has just passed a long-mooted law to fast-track citizenship applications for refugees from surrounding countries who are Hindu, Christian, Parsi, Jain or Buddhist – but not Muslim.
Critics argue the legislation is unconstitutional and undermines India’s secular ethos. In contrast to neighbouring Pakistan, an Islamic republic, India’s founding leaders were adamant that their country would not have an official religion. More than 80% of the country is Hindu, but India also has the third largest Muslim population in the world and one of the oldest Christian communities outside the Middle East.
People in India’s north-east, protective of their distinctive cultures and long suspicious that those cultures might be diluted by migrants, are also unhappy. They say they do not want refugees from neighbouring Bangladesh to become citizens of their states, whatever their religion. Some of the fiercest protests against this bill have been in north-eastern states such as Assam.
This week the demonstrations were fuelled by scenes of police beating protesters from Aligarh and Jamia university who were demonstrating against the law. Footage of young people, including many women in religious garments, being attacked by officers or stuck in a library that was being teargassed have shocked Indians and crystallised the concerns of opponents of the prime minister, Narendra Modi, that this government is eroding civil liberties.
fast-track citizenship applications for all EXCEPT Muslims? wouldnt that violate the equal protection clause? also, why are there refugees from surrounding countries? O:
SW-User
@Dewms Not fast track citizenship. The law allows Minorities who have fled from Islamic neighbour countries to India to get Indian citizenship. For the same reason many non-Muslim minorities flee to West due to persecution in Islamic states. Muslims are majority in Pakistan/ Bangladesh and India isn't bound to give their majority citizenship on that persecution groud. Also, scores of bangladeshi Muslims illegally enter through Eastern zone and that disturbs Eastern demographics. Govt wants to identify them.
SW-User
@Dewms Yes it violates the law of equality.. And Some refugees(Mostly hindus,sikhs, christians, Shia and ahmadiya muslims) are here because of religion persecution.. They won't give citizenship to muslims Not only muslims but hindus are often persecuted n srilanka They won't give citizenship to those tamils too because they're ot from pakistan , Bangladesh or Afghanistan I mean neighbouring Islamic countries. It's just the dirty politics Bjp playing If Hindus or other minorities are persecuted there we don't have problem taking them in India But you can't do the same to muslims of India what pakistan is doing to hindus
@SW-User these people don't want to talk about the negativity that the so called peaceful community has spread around the globe.... They call themselves minority when they are more than 20 % in India.... And to add to their hypocrisy these people want to impose their religion forcefully... This is what happened to Kashmiri pandits and what's happening in West Bengal.... There is no end to the list....
SW-User
@gaurangi For your kind information not only muslims but hindu muslims christians everyone is protesting against CAA NRC stop blind following... I can tell you Alot of attcks or damage Caused to this world by NON MUSLIMS but I'm not a bigot like you. I respected every religion.
@QuixoticSoul according to them yes.... It's really strange!! These people say Islam is religion of peace and on the other side they say that in Pakistan and Bangladesh muslims are persecutedd by muslims..... Wow !!what a beautiful religion.....
@QuixoticSoul count sikh, jain, budh, Christians, parsi, and so many other religion in 70 %.to 80%... Now you would get what's really maths is..... Even rohingya whi are inflitrators are more than 5 crore
@QuixoticSoul yes.... But in India only this religion has been appeased for vote banks.... There is no problem with people living in any area except for non Muslims in Muslim majority area...... Read about Kashmiri pandits... You would know what is their real agenda....
@QuixoticSoul if you say Hindu are 80 percent and you aren't dividing them into sikh, baudh, Christians etc then how can you discriminate ahmadia and other Muslim communities in Muslim countries...
They’re the fourth largest religion in India, with a bit under 2% of the population. And yes, a minority.
Christians aren’t Hindus either, I have no idea what you’re going on about at this point.
SW-User
@gaurangi everybody knows bhakts get information from WhatsApp university 😉.. Amit shah said there were 23% hindus in pakistan and they're decreasing for your information hindus never touched 15% and theyre increasing ...Go check yourself.. ,😂😂😂
SW-User
Even If you exclude sikhs ,christians ,jains hinduism is still a majority of 79%
@SW-User Yeah, it’s complete insanity to claim Islam is not a minority religion in India. This isn’t even something that can be debated 🤦🏻♂️
SW-User
@QuixoticSoul This always happen.. When BJP supporters can't counter with logic ad facts they tell us to go to Pakistan Why the hell should we go to Pakistan😂😂😂