Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

British people, would you be more likely to vote Labour if it supported a second referendum on Brexit?

As a Labour member and supporter of the leadership, I've generally supported the line they have taken as a compromise position. They've tried to gain acceptance by Labour leavers by honouring the referendum and also tried to gain acceptance by remainers by offering a softer version of Brexit than the Tories.

This strategy worked in the 2017 General Election when we polled well, without quite winning the election. Times have changed though and both leavers and remainers have hardened their positions. Most leavers see nothing short of a no-deal Brexit as a betrayal of what they voted for, even though the leave campaign talked about negotiating a deal and even sometimes mentioned the Norway option. Most remain voters I know who are not Labour Party members see anything less than a second referendum as a betrayal by the Labour Party. I find this attitude frustrating - even as a remain voter myself - because if Labour is going to go against an existing referendum result and a third of its voters, it can't do so lightly. The Labour voting coalition is traditionally a diverse coalition which includes (for example) northern working-class people and liberal metropolitan young professionals.

This is what it is though and much as I'd like to talk about Jeremy Corbyn's social democratic policies, its Brexit which is on most people's minds. Judging by canvassing, its possible Labour will finish third in the European elections and underscore even their own poor polling (though the Tories will be fourth or fifth).

Please comment in as much detail as you like. I really can't be arsed dealing with people being rude though and please keep it relevant. I don't mind non-Brits joining this debate as long as you are not saying ridiculous things about globalist conspiracies or whatever.

Thanks
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
MartinII · 70-79, M
Very interesting piece. You’ll understand that I’m not very likely to vote Labour myself in any event, though given the mess the Tories have got themselves into, a short dose of socialism might be no bad thing both for the country and for the future of the political parties. But a couple of points on Brexit.

First, I’m not sure you are quite right that most leavers would see anything short of a no-deal exit as a betrayal. It seems that way because of the dog’s breakfast May offered us, and many leavers, myself included, would be happy with no deal. But I also think that if a new Tory leader were to offer the Norway option, or something like it, with a promise of immediate agreement from Brussels and tacit acceptance from Labour, that would command widespread support from many leavers, though obviously not all. Quite how keen remainers would be I’m not sure!

As to a second referendum I think the crucial question is what sort of referendum. I, and I think most leavers, am adamantly opposed to the sort of thing the People’s Vote, and more recently apparently many Labour spokesmen, have been advocating - a choice between a particular leave option and remain. That, in my opinion, would be grossly unfair. But a full-scale rerun of 2016 - revoke Article 50, a simple in/out referendum, and a promise by both parties to respect the result - has much more to be said for it. Indeed, looked at dispassionately, it’s arguably the right thing to do given the current mess.

Much more generally, you are surely absolutely right that the Labour Party has to remember its historic and potential working-class voters. Look at what has just happened in Australia!
Burnley123 · 41-45, M
@MartinII We have very different standpoints but thanks for your detailed response.