Should the House of Lords be able to pass legislation?
[youtube=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04Os9zVeVnM&t=1s]
Top | Newest First | Oldest First
Picklebobble2 · 56-60, M
Yes IF the chamber is made up of those the PUBLIC deem fit to be there !
The 'forever argument' of this place is that there many Lords who have 'power and influence' by virtue of a 'birthright'.
Either through business connections or political ones.
Although those Peers who inherit their titles are no longer able to vote on legislation, one cannot overlook their 'influence' especially on issues drawn along 'party lines'.
To be an effective 'Second chamber' it's my view that NO sitting Lord should ever feel so comfortable as to think they are there for life !
So maybe they need to be elected just as Members of Parliament are.
As to the chambers 'Make up' with particular reference to being able to vote on legislation, Well it would be nice to think a mix of business; political; social; and legal minds might be best placed to discuss; argue; find a consensus and legislate accordingly.
Like i say. It would be nice to think...
The 'forever argument' of this place is that there many Lords who have 'power and influence' by virtue of a 'birthright'.
Either through business connections or political ones.
Although those Peers who inherit their titles are no longer able to vote on legislation, one cannot overlook their 'influence' especially on issues drawn along 'party lines'.
To be an effective 'Second chamber' it's my view that NO sitting Lord should ever feel so comfortable as to think they are there for life !
So maybe they need to be elected just as Members of Parliament are.
As to the chambers 'Make up' with particular reference to being able to vote on legislation, Well it would be nice to think a mix of business; political; social; and legal minds might be best placed to discuss; argue; find a consensus and legislate accordingly.
Like i say. It would be nice to think...
View 14 more replies »
oneperson · 31-35, M
you poor thing
Picklebobble2 · 56-60, M
@oneperson And your responses show both a clear lack of understanding of the issue and a childishness that you should really be beyond.
oneperson · 31-35, M
yup