Random
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Have you heard of Hamilton 68?

Read about it in the latest Twitter Files. It was a left-wing think tank that spread thousands of fake Russia claims on social media from 2016-2020.
That's likely where most of the Russia stuff going around now started.
NOPE.

Hamilton 68 was an attempt to identify networks of Russian bots on twitter. They published what they were doing on a "dashboard."


CLAIM: The Hamilton 68 project deceived reporters.

FACTS: Throughout the project, ASD and the Hamilton 68 team engaged with almost all reporters who approached us in good faith to understand the tool. This included participating in reports that were highly critical of the project and methodology, but that we hoped would clarify misrepresentations of the data. We also consistently pushed back against misrepresentations of our data in media reports. This included engaging with conservative media outlets to dispute claims, based on our data, that incorrectly labelled conservative hashtag campaigns—specifically one supporting Laura Ingraham—as having Russian origins.

CLAIM: Hamilton 68 “will take conversations in conservative circles on Twitter and accuse them of being Russian”.

FACTS: This claim is not supported by the data. Almost every day the dashboard was operational, the most used hashtags and key phrases focused on Ukraine, Russia, and Syria. Below is a screengrab from February 14, 2018, the day of the mass shooting in Parkland, Florida.

Dshhh · M
the russians have much more organized and well supported propaganda outlets
like


then look our for fuzzy bear
Moreover, the dashboard aggregated the domains most “linked-to” by monitored accounts. While those domains included some right-leaning American media outlets, the domains were almost exclusively Russian state media, Russian-linked, or overtly pro-Kremlin in tweets related to foreign policy issues. The below chart shows the most cited domains in tweets mentioning Syria and Ukraine during the first year of Hamilton 68’s existence. In both cases, RT was the most linked-to domain. The list also includes sites like Stalker Zone, a blog run by a pro-Russian separatist in Eastern Ukraine.


We also clarified this point in the follow-up post about the dashboard’s methodology:

Importantly, the dashboard also does not analyze the spread of a hashtag across the entire Twitter platform; it only tracks the frequency of a hashtag’s use by accounts monitored on the dashboard. As mentioned, these accounts are a sample of one network of Twitter accounts noted for their promotion of pro-Kremlin narratives. Data from the dashboard should therefore not be viewed as representative sample of all Russian-linked accounts online. This means that the preponderance of themes on the dashboard that appear to be aimed at Americans on the right or far-right of the political spectrum should not necessarily be viewed as evidence that the Kremlin has disproportionately targeted that segment of the population. Rather, it simply serves as evidence of the network’s attempts to amplify and exploit themes that resonate with a specific audience of Americans.

 
Post Comment