Fun
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

On this day November 20th

On This Day - 20th November

868 St. Edmund, Saxon king of East Anglia, was martyred by the Vikings, who tied him to a tree, shot at him with arrows, then beheaded him.



1521 Arabs attribute the shortage of water in Jerusalem to Jews making wine.




1755 William Pitt the Elder is dismissed from his post as Paymaster General after opposing the government's foreign subsidies.




..
The Cordillera of the Andes Boundary Case signed on 20th November 1902 established the present day boundaries between Argentina and Chile. It confirmed that Y Wladfa the Welsh settlement in Chubut Province in the region of Patagonia, lay in Argentina.

Previous to 1865, when the Andean Patagonian valleys had been settled by Welsh emigrants, the area was largely unexplored and of little interest to either Argentina or Chile. However, towards the end of the 19th Century, both countries had claims on it and armed conflict became a distinct probability.

In 1902, the UK agreed to mediate between the two countries. Commissioners took the views of the inhabitants of the Welsh settlements such as Trevelin and Esquel and decided in the favour of Argentina.
..







It was reported on 20th November 1908 that the North and South Wales Bank had been absorbed into the London City and Midland Bank, bringing an end to independent banking in Wales.





For his actions on 20th November 1917 during World War I, Captain Richard William Leslie Wain of Penarth was posthumously awarded the Victoria Cross.
Despite being seriously injured he attacked an enemy position in Cambrai, France, capturing it and taking prisoners. His actions enabled the infantry, which had been impeded by machine gun fire, to advance. He was killed while continuing to fire on the retreating enemy.







1944 World War II: The end of the 'blackout' in London. After five years in the dark, the lights were switched back on in Piccadilly Circus, the Strand and in Fleet Street.



1945 Nuremberg war trials begin as 24 Nazi leaders are put on trial before judges representing the victorious Allied powers.



1947 Princess Elizabeth


married Lieutenant Philip Mountbatten at Westminster Abbey. The BBC made the first tele-recording of the event, which was broadcast in the US 32 hours later.
…………

20 Nov 1974
Keith Moon, drummer with The Who, collapsed during a concert at Cow Palace in Daly City, California, after taking animal tranquillisers mixed with brandy. Moon passed out over his drum kit during 'Won't Get Fooled Again' and was revived backstage, only to collapse again during 'Magic Bus'. After Moon could not continue, guitarist Pete Townshend asked the crowd if anyone could play drums. 19-year-old Scott Halpin volunteered and played the final three songs with the band.

…………


Pepys
Wednesday 20 November 1667

Up, and all the morning at my office shut up with Mr. Gibson, I walking and he reading to me the order books of the office from the beginning of the war, for preventing the Parliament’s having them in their hands before I have looked them over and seen the utmost that can be said against us from any of our orders, and to my great content all the morning I find none.

So at noon home to dinner with my clerks, who have of late dined frequently with me, and I do purpose to have them so still, by that means I having opportunity to talk with them about business, and I love their company very well.

All the morning Mr. Hater and the boy did shut up themselves at my house doing something towards the finishing the abstract book of our contracts for my pocket, which I shall now want very much. After dinner I stayed at home all the afternoon, and Gibson with me; he and I shut up till about ten at night. We went through all our orders, and towards the end I do meet with two or three orders for our discharging of two or three little vessels by ticket without money, which do plunge me; but, however, I have the advantage by this means to study an answer and to prepare a defence, at least for myself.

So he gone I to supper, my mind busy thinking after our defence in this matter, but with vexation to think that a thing of this kind, which in itself brings nothing but trouble and shame to us, should happen before all others to become a charge against us.


This afternoon Mr. Mills come and visited me, and stayed a little with me (my wife being to be godmother to his child to-morrow), and among other talk he told me how fully satisfactory my first Report was to the House in the business of Chatham: which I am glad to hear; and the more, for that I know that he is a great creature of Sir R. Brookes’s.
Top | New | Old
ninalanyon · 70-79, T
You have a knack of turning up odd snippets that make me wonder:

1521 Arabs attribute the shortage of water in Jerusalem to Jews making wine.

Does this mean that the Arabs didn't understand how wine is made? Or was the Jewish winemaking that they referred to something different from what winemaking is now?
@ninalanyon I have tried to find more about this…got nowhere.
ninalanyon · 70-79, T
@TheSirfurryanimalWales I couldn't think how to get started on that particular search.
ninalanyon · 70-79, T
@TheSirfurryanimalWales It belatedly occurred to me that this is exactly the kind of textual research that Large Language Models, a.k.a. AIs, are good at. So I asked Anthropic Claude to explain the assertion and in response to this prompt:
Please explain this assertion: "In 1521 Arabs attribute the shortage of water in Jerusalem to Jews making wine."
it gave me this:

The assertion refers to a drought-era incident in Ottoman Jerusalem, usually dated to 20 Kislev 5282, which is 20 November 1521. The sources I found are mostly popular Jewish history sites, so the details are not independently verified.

**What happened**

The account goes back to Rabbi Moshe Basola, an Italian Jewish traveler who visited Jerusalem shortly after the Ottoman conquest. He wrote that when God did not send rain, local Muslims said the Jews' wine drinking was to blame, and asked the governor to have the Jews' wine jugs broken. On that date the governor pressed the accusation until the Jewish community agreed to pay a fine of 200 dukats. Anyone who made wine was also fined, at a rate based on the quantity produced. The "Arabs" in the assertion are the local Muslim population. In the original context the governor was an Ottoman official.

**The underlying logic**

This was a recurring "rain libel." The idea was that drought was divine punishment for sin, and that non-Muslims drinking and making wine was one such sin. Scarce water was treated as a sign of God's displeasure rather than a practical problem, so a minority could be blamed and made to pay.

**It was a pattern, not a one-off**

- A Czech pilgrim who visited in 1491 reported that during droughts people broke the wine vessels of Jews and Christians, saying God withheld rain because of the "infidels" and their wine.
- A student of Rabbi Ovadiah of Bartenura repeated the same story in 1495.
- Later sources describe similar episodes, including a 1639 famine after a long drought, when a Jewish convert to Islam convinced the Turks that the Jews' sinning was the cause.

**Caveats**

- The account is a single Jewish traveler's report, not an official record, so the exact numbers and wording rest on his testimony.
- Some modern retellings, such as the OU's daily-history entry, use the incident to draw a line to present-day water disputes. That is a rhetorical framing, not part of the historical record.
- Jerusalem's water problems were real and long-standing, with a decaying aqueduct system and reliance on cisterns, so the shortage itself was genuine. The wine explanation was the scapegoating layer.

If you tell me where you saw the assertion, I can help judge how it was being used.
So it doesn't strictly relate to the making of wine but rather to the sin, in Muslim eyes, of drinking it. And the drought is not caused by the wine making but is god's punishment for drinking alcohol.

 
Post Comment