Update
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Space X rocket testing plant over pumped 128 million gallons of groundwater in three years;

Now this Texas city has to pay $175,000 in penalties and fund a new monitoring system.

Elon Musk's SpaceX violated groundwater rules, and a Texas city has to pay thousands of dollars for the same. The US city of McGregor has agreed to pay at least $175,000 in penalties after SpaceX's rocket testing operation allegedly overpumped 128 million gallons of groundwater over three years. The city owns the site and the wells SpaceX used, making it responsible for the penalties under a settlement with the Southern Trinity Groundwater Conservation District.

The deal includes a $50,000 payment due by November 1, followed by quarterly payments of $1,250 for 25 years to fund a new groundwater monitoring system. McGregor must also show “reasonable efforts to obtain additional sources of water” as concerns continue over groundwater supplies in the region.

The McGregor City Council approved the negotiated settlement on Monday, avoiding a potential district court battle with the groundwater district.

The Southern Trinity Groundwater Conservation District issued violation notices to SpaceX and McGregor for each of the past three years over groundwater use totalling 128 million gallons..

McGregor City Manager Kevin Evans said the city was satisfied with the outcome and pointed to SpaceX's efforts to reduce its potable water use.

“We’re very satisfied with the outcome,” McGregor City Manager Kevin Evans said Tuesday. “Water will always be an issue. We’re working with SpaceX and everyone else in the industrial park to use less potable water.”

Evans said SpaceX has also been working to reuse water at its McGregor facility. The city is exploring alternative sources, including buying groundwater from other communities or obtaining Belton Lake water through Bluebonnet Water Supply Corp.

Under the settlement, McGregor will make a one-time $50,000 payment by November 1 and then pay $1,250 every quarter for the next 25 years.

The payments will help fund a new groundwater monitoring system on the well used by SpaceX. The city must also make “reasonable efforts to obtain additional sources of water.”

Evans said SpaceX has already scaled back its groundwater use and expects no further conflicts with the groundwater district. He also noted that the penalty will be paid from proceeds from a sale of city property rather than tax revenue.

McGregor Mayor Jim Lilley suggested that concerns about groundwater depletion may be overstated.

“There’s plenty of water in the aquifer,” he said. “This last year that we over pumped our permit number just proved that there’s plenty of water in the aquifer.”

Southern Trinity Groundwater Conservation District president Rodney Kroll disagreed, saying the aquifer does not recharge.

“Our aquifer does not recharge,” Kroll said. “We’re very unique in that regard. … What that says ultimately is that the water level is going down annually, and someday, we’ll reach a point where there’s no (ground)water.”

Kroll said that point could come within about 50 years.

The countywide groundwater district was formed in 2008 after state regulators determined that the region faced “critical” groundwater shortages in coming decades.

The settlement has also drawn criticism from McGregor residents because SpaceX drove most groundwater use.

“SpaceX is the primary driver for over pumping these wells, and they’re not responsible for the litigation, they’re not responsible for the fees, and they’re not responsible for the attorney’s costs,” said McGregor resident Danny Campbell. “They’re not responsible for any of it, and every dollar that goes towards things like this is one dollar taken from our community.”

Source: India Times
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/technology/tech-news/spacexs-rocket-testing-plant-overpumped-128-million-gallons-of-groundwater-in-three-years-now-this-texas-city-has-to-pay-175000-in-penalties-and-fund-a-new-monitoring-system/articleshow_comments/134743244.cms
Top | New | Old
ArishMell · 70-79, M
Oh the old damage-limiting dodge so many big organisations use when caught out. Its normal pattern is something like this:

"We welcome the findings of...."
The body who investigated and published the wrongdoing, negligence, incompetence, greed or failure.

"and are very satisfied with ... "
having been caught out.

"...and will work with our partners....."
i.e. those who revealed it, and the victims.


This is sometimes continued by:

"We have learnt lessons...."
Can anyone remember them?

"and have put procedures in place to ensure it can never it happen again".
Only it will, because a) the more procedures, the less the staff can use their skill and initiative, and b) the procedues may reduce the risk of failing in the same way, but not of failing generally.


The stock managerial-waffle response continues,

"We are reviewing the findings and our processes to..."
appear to outsiders to be putting things right, but really are striving to avoid doing so,

"and are committed to ensuring.. "
which carefully avoids saying we will act to right our own wrongs / inaction / ineptitude / greed / maladministration / ... but perhaps our successors will.

"...going forward."
Tautological, but it does not say when.


Effectively, SpaceX is following much of that.

Only its wrongdoing will continue and its victims are those penalised for it.

The wrong is not righted, simply moved to affect wider areas and their people while penalising the existing victims.

Unfortunately, Texas, your biggest stumbling-block here is not inept or negligent local managers but the Great Untouchable, never brought to account for his responsibilities - a bloke called Elon Musk.
whowasthatmaskedman · 70-79, M
So, in effect, these "fines"are the price of SpaceX just doing anything it wants with the water. Its not a penalty. Its a business expense😷
FreddieUK · 70-79, M
Once again the man with the money to pay this (comparatively for a trillionaire) paltry sum gets off with a shrug of the shoulders. The sooner he ships himself off to Mars the better.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
@FreddieUK I wonder why he is allowed to ignore all responsibility for anything he does.
FreddieUK · 70-79, M
@ArishMell Political protection.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
@FreddieUK Yes - a sort of mutual-support network par excellence.

 
Post Comment