This post may contain Mildly Adult content.
Mildly AdultRandom
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

AP Stylebook Issues Guide for Transgender Coverage

The Associated Press Stylebook, which for decades has served as the default style manual for most news organizations, has issued a “Topical Guide” for transgender coverage that encourages writers to not give a platform to non-'woke' claims and sources in an attempt to balance a story by including all views.

The guidance appears to explicitly embrace the language and claims of transgender activists, a move likely to steer newsrooms away from objectively framing the issue.

The AP Stylebook has issued prior guidance related to gender and sexuality, and some of that is repackaged in the Topical Guide. But it does include some updates, together providing an extensive reference for journalists.

The Transgender Coverage Topical Guide encourages writers to refer to subjects according to their preferred gender identity. The guide condemns referring to a transgender person’s previous name.

The guide explains that the word “identify” can be useful, but “‘is a woman’ is better than ‘identifies as a woman.’”

The guide describes the term “sex” by explaining “a person’s sex is usually assigned at birth by parents or attendants, sometimes inaccurately” and further advises writers to “avoid terms like ‘biological male."

The guide criticizes efforts to maintain sex-specific sports and denies that men have an athletic advantage over cisgender women.

There is updated guidance on characterizing pregnancy as well. Previously, the AP Stylebook had endorsed the gender-neutral framing “pregnant people,” explaining that “the inclusive term ‘pregnant people’ is preferred when describing people who are pregnant. It takes into account pregnant men and nonbinary people.

In 2017, AP Stylebook embraced “they” as a singular, gender-neutral pronoun.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
How are you a "different drummer" when you're beating the same tired "I'm so oppressed" tune?

"They has always been a singular, gender-neutral pronoun." Example:

"Someone forgot their wallet. I'll hang onto it until they come back for it."

If this person didn't have bottom surgery and became pregnant, would you call him a "pregnant woman" because he was born female? Wouldn't "pregnant person" be more appropriate? Would you prefer for him to use the men's room or the ladies' room?
@LeopoldBloom Nowhere do I claim to be "oppressed." That's your first misperception — in your first sentence.

If this person didn't have bottom surgery and became pregnant, would you call him a "pregnant woman" because he was born female?

I would call HER a "pregnant woman" because SHE was born female. Your second misperception is that a woman is a man because she thinks she'd like to be. Worse, you think others have to pretend she is.
@DffrntDrmmr OK, so if "she" uses the ladies room and your wife or daughter complains about a "man in there," you'll set her straight.

If you think Buck Angel only "thinks" he's a man, congratulations, you've just shown yourself to be either an anti-trans bigot or an ignoramus.

So if your workplace requires you to refer to a trans employee by their preferred pronoun, you wouldn't consider yourself "oppressed?" OK, whatever.
@LeopoldBloom Yes, I'd have to explain some women pretend to be men.

I don't know who Buck Angel is and I suspect I shouldn't care that I don't.

I don't work for someone else so that's not an issue. I'm not oppressed. Any company with that policy is absurd.
@DffrntDrmmr You'd get a big surprise if you hit on this one.
@LeopoldBloom Yep, probably. I once was bar-hopping and a girl smiled as we passed. I stopped to talk with her for several minutes. I saw nothing out of the ordinary, but as we parted my friend goes, "that's a guy. It's drag night." 😬
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
@Punches I've noticed that many anti-gay men are in fact closeted gays. It seems every few months another one is outed, most recently, Pastor Jesse Lee Peterson, an anti-LGBT pastor who has said that women should not orgasm during sex because "this makes them a man." Peterson was outed when several of his male sex partners came forward.
Punches · 46-50, F
@LeopoldBloom I think it is true. Usually those who speak the loudest also have the most to hide.
What I do NOT understand though is why some women, like my ex room mate's mom, are so against TG.
@LeopoldBloom Another misperception by you. I'm not anti-gay, not at all, never have been. I'm very tolerant of other people's choices... live and let live, I say. Our most important right is the right to express ourselves freely.

My objection to AP's Stylebook on trans coverage is because it's intolerant of freedom of thought and is an clear attempt at oppression and censorship. AP's policy guide is used widely in the news journalism industry and is majorly influential.

Journalism school will teach how to balance a controversial story with a writers neutral stance, which sometimes includes conventional or points from "the other side" to be fair. AP is saying 'don't do that on trans reporting. Ignore them and only use trans activists thinking and terminology, even when it's baseless.'

Biased news is a problem, and this is a key reason why. This is how lock-step Democrats have gotten so far off track.

I'm against Democrats oppression and intolerance — you see it in their authoritarian tendencies, their rigid control of narrative and terminology, their intolerance of others choices, their intolerance of free speech, their cancel culture, their mob attack culture.

That has nothing to do with what your irrational mind comes up with.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
This message was deleted by the author of the main post.
Punches · 46-50, F
@DffrntDrmmr
You're a nasty troll, nothing more. I will ignore you from now on.

Good, you are full of it anyways. 😁