Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Do you think the song eclipse by Pink Floyd

Would be better if the Beatles would’ve done it ?
helenS · 36-40, F
You mean if the Beatles had done the arrangement? Probably not.
Jonjdw · 46-50, M
@helenS if the Beatles would’ve wrote it and sang it. But also if the Beatles just would’ve sang it with their own style. Either way doesn’t really matter if the Beatles would’ve sang the song in any way.

I’m not a Beatles fan.
helenS · 36-40, F
@Jonjdw I think McCartney was a decent songwriter in the pop/rock genre; of course he was no Harold Arlen.
Axeroberts · 56-60, M
No but they might be a good candidate along with the old Genesis
DragonFruit · 61-69, M
No, each band had its own vision and each was beautiful and brilliant....but each was also unique.
I wouldn't presume that the Beatles would have done any better, as this was Pink Floyd's vision (in fact, they probably wouldn't have done it quite as brilliantly).
SpudMuffin · 61-69, M
No, absolutely not!
[media=https://youtu.be/4Z8olHzeaKE]
Turn the sound up…
DDonde · 31-35, M

 
Post Comment