Top | Newest First | Oldest First
Elegy · 46-50
NIN but I like them both. Two very different reads. One is angst the other a lament.
SW-User
johnny.
UnsureForNow · 41-45, M
Johnny's is definitely more emotional, heart-wrenching, touching.
SW-User
@UnsureForNow: it also helps if you know his personal details during that time frame.
UnsureForNow · 41-45, M
@hatred: Of course. It's an all-time classic, an amazing performance, and the fact that he died just months later makes it that much more incredible.
Musically and artistically though.....
Musically and artistically though.....
Ynotjenn · F
This song makes me sad :/
AbbeyRhode · F
Johnny.
NigelDoes · 56-60, M
You're kidding right? Please tell me you're kidding..
UnsureForNow · 41-45, M
I'm not kidding.
Johnny's is certainly emotional, and can't be watched without shedding a single tear. But musically, I prefer the original.
Johnny's is certainly emotional, and can't be watched without shedding a single tear. But musically, I prefer the original.
UnsureForNow · 41-45, M
And I know...even Trent Reznor says that it isn't his song anymore, and that song belongs to Johnny. Just opening it up for discussion.
SW-User
Nine Inch Nails its his song
UnsureForNow · 41-45, M
As far as the song goes, I prefer the NiN version.
SW-User
I've heard it played live and its just as good 20 years later
MartinTheFirst · 26-30, M
John without a doubt.