Upset
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Legally guilty people aren't always morally guilty.

The law is idealistic. It's desgined to encourage perfect behavior, and legislators know that. When they create laws, they imagine, "What SHOULD people do in this situation?" That doesn't take into account when you or I or they would personally do. If a person hurts another person in a way that isn't legally recognized, and the victim of that moral crime retaliates, they may do something that's legally recognized as harm. And so the law will pursue and prosecute that person. That's not an even distribution of punishment.

But for the rest of that person's life, they'll be recognized as a criminal. They'll be set apart from you and me for a reason that's no different than you and me.

That's why idgaf what the law says. If a person has a conviction, I hardly care. I look at them with my own eyes. Not the eyes of the law.

And plenty of legally "innocent" people are guilty of worse things.
Ontheroad · M
And that's why we have jury trials. A jury can find you innocent when by the letter of the law, you are guilty... the reverse is also true. The idea of a jury is to bring justice to the system. Does it always work? No, of course not; but it does bring some balance.

I think a great example is the current case in New York - the one where a physically larger and much younger man assaults the owner of a store for basically no reason other than he can. The older man and smaller man, the store owner clearly fears for his life and fights back with a knife, killing the assailant. By law, the store owner by using a knife used undue deadly force. However, it is already clear no jury is going to convict him.
SinlessOnslaught · 26-30, M
@Ontheroad Make a post here on SW that outlines an unpopular opinion you have and determine if it's correct or not based on what the first 12 viewers think.
Such a post coming from this user's account whom I have mostly seen making funny posts is a nice surprise.
Be well.
AJS30 · 31-35, M
Legality isn't morality. Legality is an arbitrary system by legal mafias aka governments. Legal is whatever the government wants it to be at any given time. Legal doesn't mean moral and illegal doesn't mean immoral. They only refer to whether the government allows it or not. Something is either immoral or it's not. Something either has a victim or it doesn't. Something is either a crime or it's not.
SW-User
Good post ❤️

 
Post Comment