Would you ever act as witness to an execution ?

Even with no question that the convicted had committed an especially heinous crime ?
(If you are completely anti-death penalty under all circumstances, this question is obviously not directed at you)

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

BlobbyMcBlobface · 100+, M

With today's technology and DNA proving murderers guilty beyond doubt I'd gladly pull the lever or press the button. Acting as witness would be a mere walk in the park.

Alyosha · 36-40, M

@BlobbyMcBlobface You're overconfidant in the extreme. Get help.

BlobbyMcBlobface · 100+, M

@Alyosha In what way am I over confident? If a murderer is guilty beyond doubt then what's the problem with him/her facing the ultimate penalty? Please explain. You seem like a lefty to me.

Alyosha · 36-40, M

@BlobbyMcBlobface I didn't contradict your hypothetical. I just recognize the reality of fallible humans rendering judgment on life and death. Especially in current circumstances, there are likely to be failures of justice.

BlobbyMcBlobface · 100+, M

@Alyosha Guilty beyond doubt means exactly that. I understand now that other factors can influence the decision of a jury in the US so I apologise for my ignorance concerning that. However, i do not apologise for believing that the actual murderer of a victim has no right to breathe oxygen any longer than is necessary before his/her expiration.

bijouxbroussard · F

@BlobbyMcBlobface Unfortunately, in the US the Law Enforcement/Justice System and the Healthcare industry are two areas where it really is "your money or your life". Regardless of the crime, if you’re wealthy you’re unlikely to get the death penalty, if only because of the quality of the defense you can afford.