Upset
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

[Opinion]How concerned are you right now about homelessness?

Poll - Total Votes: 36
1. Very concerned
2. Somewhat concerned
3. A little concerned
4. Not concerned at all
Show Results
You can only vote on one answer.
Found an interesting poll about homelessness on The Hill website which I found a bit alarming. I find it alarming that 19% just don't care at all. It has over a million responses. Just wondering if you feel the same way?

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Ferise1 · 46-50, M
I asked ChatGPT how to fix it

That’s a big, serious question — and thank you for trusting me with it. I’ll answer plainly, not idealistically.

Homelessness isn’t one problem. It’s several different problems that get lumped together. Any solution that treats “the homeless” as one group will fail.

1. First principle: housing comes first (but not only housing)

The evidence is overwhelming: you cannot fix anything else if someone has no stable place to sleep.

So step one is guaranteed, immediate housing:
• Small, simple private units (not giant shelters)
• No sobriety or employment requirements to enter
• Safety, warmth, and a lock on the door

This alone drastically reduces:
• Emergency room costs
• Police involvement
• Long-term public spending

This is not charity — it’s cheaper than doing nothing.

But housing alone doesn’t solve homelessness. It just makes solving it possible.

2. Separate people into reality-based categories

This is where governments usually fail.

A. People who fell out of the system

• Job loss
• Divorce
• Rent spikes
• Medical bills
• Burnout

Fix:
• Short-term housing
• Admin help (paperwork, debt negotiation, benefits)
• Job matching, not “training for imaginary jobs”

Most people in this group are back on their feet within months.

B. People with untreated mental illness

• Psychosis
• Severe depression
• Trauma
• Paranoia

Fix:
• Mandatory but humane psychiatric evaluation after housing
• Long-term care options (not prisons, not streets)
• Caseworkers with authority, not just “suggestions”

Leaving severely ill people to “choose” the street is not freedom — it’s abandonment.

C. Addiction-driven homelessness

This is the most controversial part, but honesty matters.

Fix:
• Medicalized addiction treatment
• Safe supply where needed
• Structured programs with real accountability
• Long-term follow-up, not 30-day miracles

You don’t punish addiction, but you also don’t pretend it disappears with a pamphlet.

D. People who reject the system entirely

A small but real group.

Fix:
• Offer housing repeatedly
• Set firm public-space rules
• Provide alternatives, but no permanent street encampments

Compassion does not mean surrendering public spaces indefinitely.

3. Fix the systems that create homelessness

This is the unglamorous part politicians avoid.

Housing market

• Build a lot of boring, dense housing
• Legalize smaller units
• Kill zoning laws that protect property values over human lives

Healthcare

• Universal mental healthcare
• Early intervention
• No one should become homeless because they got sick

Bureaucracy

• One caseworker per person
• Paperwork done for people, not handed to them
• Missed appointments ≠ punishment

4. Stop moralizing

This is crucial.
• Homelessness is not a personal failure
• It’s also not romantic rebellion
• It’s a systems failure with human faces

The public wants the homeless to be either:
• Saints who just need kindness
or
• Villains who deserve punishment

They are neither. They’re people under pressure.

5. The uncomfortable truth

If a society truly wanted to end homelessness, it could.

What stops it is not lack of money or knowledge — it’s:
• NIMBYism
• Political cowardice
• The fear of rewarding “bad behavior”
• The discomfort of admitting that many people are one bad year away from the street

In one sentence:

I would fix homelessness by guaranteeing housing first, treating mental illness and addiction as medical issues, enforcing public-space rules fairly, and redesigning housing and healthcare systems to prevent people from falling through in the first place.

If you want, I can also:
• Apply this specifically to Switzerland
• Explain why some cities fail despite spending billions
• Or talk about what doesn’t work and why people keep trying it anyway
DeWayfarer · 61-69, M
@Ferise1 Thank you for that ChatGPT analysis.

Yet very likely for the wrong reasoning.

ChatGPT has a serious tendency to respond in context relatable to both the context of the statements as well as the location in the world.

What this analysis has confirmed is that ChatGPTs responses are as well location based. I have long suspected this, yet it's wording has confirmed this.

ChatGPT never says "thank you" quite that way in the USA versions.
Docdon23 · M
@Ferise1 Loved this answer. It all makes sense and is actually doable--if we have the will. I think sometimes people with money or comforts are afraid reducing homelessness somehow will take away their money or privilege. Not true.
DeWayfarer · 61-69, M
@Docdon23 ChatGPT just confirmed my suspicion though. It does base it's statements on culture.

A Chinese version of this would never be so capitalistic.

The EU as well has different views on capitalism, than the USA, though not as pronounced as with China.