Which is better ... ?

Simon and Garfunkel - hands down.

The other version is too dark. It takes away from the song's original nuance.
What's next, a dark rendering of the 59th street bridge song? (also, he needs to open his mouth and enunciate his words. It sounds like his lower jaw is wired in place).

I really like Disturbed's version.

i like both for me the second one is better. More intense.

The first, for some reason the second sounds like Christmas music

I love both versions but Disturbed feels more powerful to me.

The original for me.

I usually hate covers, but I like Disturbed. I like both versions, for different reasons.

Simon and garfunkel

S&G

I seem to be the only person on the planet that prefers those nice Jewish boys original version.