Random
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Why are “food groups” a thing?

The modern concept of “food groups” is honestly pretty silly and arbitrary. There are constant debates on whether tomatoes are fruits or vegetables. Well, biologically speaking, they are fruits, but what is a “vegetable” anyway? Just any edible plant? In that case, all fruits would be vegetables too. Apples are edible plants, as are watermelons. Mushrooms are traditionally called “vegetables” too, but they aren’t plants at all. They’re fungi. But “fungi” aren’t a food group. They aren’t meat by any means, so what food group are they?

And what about grains? What are grains? They’re considered a “food group,” but are they not edible plants as well? What distinguishes corn or rice from any other plant? Fruits, grains, and “vegetables,” whatever that even means, are all edible plants—except mushrooms.

What about plant-based “meats?” Is a soy burger a vegetable, a meat, or a grain?

I suppose meat and dairy are the most concrete and definable. Meat is an animal’s muscle, and dairy is an animal’s milk (or things made from that milk). But then you could ask…is soy milk or coconut milk dairy…or is it a vegetable?

It’s all quite silly and arbitrary. Food is food. 🤷‍♂️
Heartlander · 80-89, M
:) yes, confusing

I believe tomatoes are legally a vegetable. That distinction was made in a court of law someplace or other where vegetables were taxed and fruit weren't.

Are peanuts really nuts? Shouldn't they be legumes?

Watermelons, muskmelons, squash, pumpkins, cucumbers are all first cousins.

Food groups are just categories to help people get the best mix of protein, carbs and fats. And within those macro-nutrients there is additional subdivision that provide different micro-nutrients, vitamins, minerals, etc. The old food guide pyramid did a pretty good job with the horizontal layout to show the proportional importance of the different subgroups. The distinction between fruits and vegetables are less about the differences and more because many popular fruits are sugar intense, or processed to be such, and consuming more than just a tiny amounts of sugars, fructose, (or whatever they call it) is generally discouraged.
RedBaron · M
Food groups are multiple things, not "a thing."
cherokeepatti · 61-69, F
Don’t overthink it too much
This comment is hidden. Show Comment

 
Post Comment