Something we both agree on..what matters most to me is enjoying each others company

I’d be fine with a peanut butter and jelly sandwich in a picnic basket

Something we could try out and share together.

I like fancy Indian resturaunts for dates.

Always check with your date first to find out what sorts of weird food things they have going on. Some people are Vegan. Some are vegetarians but will eat cheese.
Some people hate seafood. Some people can't stand chocolate. Some people can't eat gluten, or dairy, or might have a peanut allergy.

Bar food.

This isn’t exactly what you asked but in my bachelor days, my traditional second date meal would be to invite my date over for a home-cooked dinner.

I cooked Italian for my husband our first official date.

Burger and fries

Probably do Italian.

Probably pizza lol