This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
I question this... as some how it's misleading (the science, not you Bexy).
You lift something that is one pound, and then release it and it drops, because it's heavier or more dense than the air.
The clouds aren't doing that, so therefore they aren't heavier or more dense than the air.
Therefore, in their current state, they must be less than 1 lb, correct?
So to get them to the 1.1 million pounds measurements, they must be changing their state to water and ice, before measuring them, correct?
Otherwise, it just doesn't make sense in my mind right now, but if I'm wrong then maybe it's a me thing.
You lift something that is one pound, and then release it and it drops, because it's heavier or more dense than the air.
The clouds aren't doing that, so therefore they aren't heavier or more dense than the air.
Therefore, in their current state, they must be less than 1 lb, correct?
So to get them to the 1.1 million pounds measurements, they must be changing their state to water and ice, before measuring them, correct?
Otherwise, it just doesn't make sense in my mind right now, but if I'm wrong then maybe it's a me thing.
Livingwell · 61-69, M
@sstronaut Weight and Density are different properties but related. A square foot of water and air occupy the same space but have vastly different densities. If you boiled that water, the weight would be the same but its density would decrease becoming steam or water vapor. While a cloud has immense weight, its density is very low allowing air pressure to suspend the water from below. Think a boat on water. The take away is that cloud is incredibly large but due to its altitude, our perspective of that is distorted.
@Livingwell thanks! I'm still reading more.
science nerd girl coming alive in me. I. Need. More. Knowledge
science nerd girl coming alive in me. I. Need. More. Knowledge
Livingwell · 61-69, M
@Bexsy Yes!!!! Nerd girls are awesome!
@Livingwell I agree that it's huge and I noted they used a cubic kilometer, which is HUGE!
But if you combine that cloud to weigh it, it turns into water (or rain) and it falls.
To my limited knowledge, we don't have an ability to measure a specific cloud while it's in the gas state. We have to judge it by it's solid state... and calculated from there. At least to my limited knowledge.
Maybe I'm wrong about this
But if you combine that cloud to weigh it, it turns into water (or rain) and it falls.
To my limited knowledge, we don't have an ability to measure a specific cloud while it's in the gas state. We have to judge it by it's solid state... and calculated from there. At least to my limited knowledge.
Maybe I'm wrong about this
JimboSaturn · 56-60, M
@sstronaut They are less dense than air hence they float.
Livingwell · 61-69, M
@sstronaut We can easily weigh gasses, water vapor, etc. From there we can determine it's volume at the specific altitude pressure and we then calculate its weight. When temperature changes (cools) the water vapor cools and becomes larger droplets until it drops as rain.