Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Who was in the wrong, teacher or student?

I'm a 16 year old female in highschool, 3 weeks into my junior year.
I was in chemistry class with a teacher who talks in a condescending manner, I think it's unintentional though.
She passed out a paper to every student and wanted us to do that for the period.
I didn't understand so I raised my hand and asked for help on how to do it, but when she heard my question all she said was "No. You should understand this" and walked away.
That annoyed me. She's the teacher, why can't she help me understand?
5 minutes later she walks by my desk and sees there's no answers on my paper.
"Come on you need to get this done" she said.
"Miss I don't understand, I need help" I replied
She said to keep reading the directions and charts until I understood.
Wow, that's irritating.
10 minutes go by and I have nothing except my name, date, and period.
"You need to work on your reading" she said
I read just fine, at an above college level.
"I don't understand what it's asking" I said a little louder, unintentionally.
She thought I was yelling
15 minutes still nothing (I didn't have my phone and we were not allowed to talk)
I started bouncing my leg in frustration and clenched my fists as I always do when angry when she bent down to my desk and lectures me on my "reading struggles" Deep breaths were took and my eyes started to water from the anger.
She asked if I need to take a walk. I said you and walked out of the room.
I didn't come back until 5 minutes before the end of the period, so I was gone for around 30 to 40 minutes.
She said something about it when I went back in but nothing important.
She then messaged me through the grading app we have and said

"Adeen, I explained protons, electrons, neutrons, and mass for the last two days. (She did not, we set up our notebooks and watched a video biology) I cannot understand something for you. You have to comprehend it. You have now missed more explanation and going over the history of atomic theory answers."

I responded with
"You should've explained it again when I asked instead of saying no. How would you saying no possibly help me in the future? You refusing to explain something is the perfect way to set up a student to fail. I read it multiple times and did not understand what it was asking. If a student has a question it's the teachers job to answer it."

(I'm also not so great with math, which this assignment had a lot of)
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
rckt148 · 61-69, M
I asked did other students have trouble ,and now you have said only 2 besides you didn't get it ,
So how is it the rest of the class except 3 didn't ?
When in training while in boot camp I was called to the hospital a lot ,
I had health issues ,so it got me behind in my class training .
Then add I was 17 and home sick ,worried someone might be trying to sweet talk my new bride while I was away ,to say I was distracted was an understatement ,
So to make a long story short ,I got held back a week .
My new Company Commander had an assistant ,and he was a real jerk ,and mean
he gets in my face and threatens me ,I better not mess up his company ,and every morning he singled me out "adjusting Ok recruit ?" Sir yes Sir
I go from the worst in the crew to the best
I learned to take very good notes on everything
When I write something down ,its gets in the brain and commits to memory
Now should she have took time and explained it to you ?
More then likely she should have ,and you and the other 2 would have understood ,
BUT , it also could have been a lesson in next time pay better attention ,even take notes .
I am glad I learned my lesson
I got to go to Base Miami Beach Florida instead of isolated duty in Alaska
Had I not got reverted ,that would have been my only choice,, Alaska

So being kept another week from my wife was my motivation
but in the end there was more to loose then I could have imagined
So do you want me to candy coat it ,and say she was wrong ,maybe she was
and maybe had you waited until after class and asked her what you were missing ,she may have explained why she did what she did ,,she did take time to text you
Maybe she will let you make it up ,with better instructions

Today people want to tell the youth "Bad Teacher "no way they were in the wrong
the teacher was to blame "thats her job" ,she is paid to teach ,,maybe she just did ,

When I teach or train now ,I often leave things off on purpose
I challenge you you to tell me if I made an error
did I leave something out
it makes you pay more attention to detail ,take notes commit things to memory
and my way beats someone threating to kick your but and punish everyone because of you .
My way makes you pay attention to detail and be self reliant ,not always looking to me .
the threat of mass punishment ,
You see what that causes ,,is others will help you ,or kick your butt when you are sleeping
it motivates a 17 yr old to go from the worst in the company to the best
no one likes a blanket party at 2 am (they literally beat the crap out of you )
I said all this to say next time ,ask questions before the exam
and read it a million times if need be instead of getting mad
some how all but 3 of you got it ,at some point ,the others heard the directions
I wont say the teacher was right or wrong ,I will say she holds your grade ,she or he is the teacher ,its best to stay on their good side ,,then they are more apt to help you
Deletedlol · 22-25, F
@rckt148 I said multiple people,and that was when I was in the room. More asked after I had left I was told. But stopped asking after she told many kids no.
Deletedlol · 22-25, F
@rckt148 And like I said, she did not teach us how to do that. I play plenty attention in school and usually get As and a few Bs. I took notes on what she did show us which was a video.
rckt148 · 61-69, M
@Deletedlol so will you feel better and go enjoy your 3 day weekend if we all say you are right ?
and maybe ask on Tuesday if she will explain the directions you did not get today
Cause today is over ,and can't be repaired ,,regardless who is right or wrong
But I do get it upset you ,you made the post
The teacher wins and you loose today ,
was she right ,I need to know her side too
and even then its only my opinion ,she controls your grade
Deletedlol · 22-25, F
@rckt148 I have training throughout the weekend. Hopefully she'll explain but I doubt it.