Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Is "from the river to the sea" a call to genocide?

Why/why not?
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Moon3624 · 18-21, F
“From the river to the sea Palestine will be free “

What’s wrong with it?
They saw their land annexed and are living under an apartheid.
They want their liberation and freedom

Just like South Africa and Algeria decolonized it self and ended violence and apartheid against their people
@Moon3624 "From the Mountains to the ocean, from the windward to the leeward side.". Is it a war cry against Americans? It's Hawaiian.
fanuc2013 · 51-55, F
@Moon3624 Look back in history, the arabs took the land from the Jews and created Palestine, and in 1948 the Jews took it back. That land has changed hands so many times no one knows who had it originally, God gave the Jews that land in the Old Testament, so does divine command carry more weight?
Moon3624 · 18-21, F
@fanuc2013
“ Look back in history, the arabs took the land from the Jews and created Palestine, ”

Nope they didn’t😂 clearly never grabbed a history book.

The Arabic army took it from the [b]Byzantines[/b] not the Jews and this was more than 1400+ years ago .
And Omar which was the second Islamic caliph at that time called back many Jewish families who were expelled from Jerusalem by the Romans back into it .
And if we look at historical records , the Arab army
Didn’t displace the indigenous population there or commit a genocide (like how Israel did!)
They just ruled over them
And over time The indigenous people converted to Islam and some didn’t convert and remained Jewish and Christian etc and adapted Arabic since it’s the language of who was ruling over them (just like Egypt today speaks Arabic despite the fact most of them decedent from ancient Egyptians)
This is why the Christian Palestinian families are some of the oldest Christian families in the world going back to the time of Jesus himself
And by the way, the whole history of Jews
Being expelled by their own god from that land
Be it 2000 years or 3000 years or 5000 years ago
is a biblical story and not actual history
That we can depend on for facts
And even jews aren’t the indigenous people to that land according to their own Torah. Their Torah states that Abraham migrated from Iraq to Palestine and that
The indigenous people of Palestine are the Canaanites and did you know that Canaanite dna is prominent in Lebanese and Palestinians?
“ The results showed that modern Lebanese can trace more than 90 percent of their genetic ancestry to Canaanites.”

Here is dna of the Palestinians compared to ashkenazi Jew :




The only “claim” Israel has is “my subjective holy book and God promised me this land and I’m God’s chosen people “
Which makes you no different than isis.
In fact worse.

Palestinians have faced more than 75 years of land annexation and theft, massacres, apartheid and violence
To this day it’s happening
There is an ongoing apartheid by Israel against the Palestinians
It’s called an apartheid state
By the UN, Harvard , amnesty and so on
Do you really have the face to say that?

And who told you there were no Jews in that land before the creation of Israel?
@fanuc2013 legitimate modern nations don't take territory by force. That's against the law - Americans kill and confuse to stop us from following laws. Human rights were the law, but Americans kill them.