The one question that Christians cannot answer. I dare any Christian to answer this question.

If God is perfect and has always been perfect. And if God is good and has always been perfectly good, then God has never had to choose to be good. And God has never had to make the choice between Good and Evil. So for God to give humans the choice between good and evil is a logical fallacy.

Why would God create humans having to choose between good and evil when he himself never had to choose between Good and Evil? Why wouldn't God make humans perfectly good like himself?

Furthermore if God is perfect and has always been perfect. And if God is good and has always been perfectly good then it is impossible for God to create evil. Because to create evil is to not be perfectly good.

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

Adstar · 56-60, M

No it's not.. Simply making the statement that it is a logical fallacy does not provide any evidence that it is a logical fallacy..

Why would God create humans having to choose between good and evil when he himself never had to choose between Good and Evil? Why wouldn't God make humans perfectly good like himself?

Well Gods eternal plan required Him to create beings with the ability to choose between good and evil.. This is so simple to answer..

Furthermore if God is perfect and has always been perfect. And if God is good and has always been perfectly good then it is impossible for God to create evil. Because to create evil is to not be perfectly good.

Creating the OPTION of pursuing Evil is not creating evil.. The only time evil is created is when the one with the choice to pursue evil decided to pursue it..

James25 · 61-69, M

@Adstar

Well Gods eternal plan required Him to create beings with the ability to choose between good and evil.. This is so simple to answer..

Your answer is a logical fallacy. How is God required to create beings with the ability to choose between Good and Evil when God himself is not required to choose between Good and Evil? If God is not required to choose between Good and Evil why would he require human beings to choose between good and evil? Not only is he requiring something that he does not require of himself but he is also requiring it from imperfect people. Your argument is not based on logical sound reasoning. And cannot be proven to be true. Your argument that it is God's Eternal plan is illogical and doesn't make any sense. Saying that it is God's Eternal plan does not answer the question. Why does God's Eternal plan require him to create beings to choose between Good and Evil when he himself has never chosen between Good and Evil?

Adstar · 56-60, M

@James25 He is not ""reqiored"" to do anything.. He could have decided not to create anything at all.. He Chose to create.. God can and did do what He deemed to do.. He created because He has an objective He deemed worthy of producing.. And that desire meant that beings where created with the ability to choose Evil or good..

The very reason we became imperfect was based on our ancestors ability to choose badly.. But again God has overcome the eternal result of our imperfection and by doing so has demonstrated to the Heavenly Host why He is the one and only God of all existence and why satan is not and never will be a god..

Proof?? i am not concerned with proving anything.. I state what is and it is up to others to take it or leave it..

Actually you as an imperfect being do not have perfect reasoning but you clearly base your views trusting on the very same imperfect reasoning.. You do not have all knowledge and therefore your basis for your ""reasoned"" POV is faulty. Trust in your own reasoning if you like... But in doing so you are standing on quicksand..

James25 · 61-69, M

@Adstar none of what you are saying actually answers the question. You are presenting an argument that is not based on some reasoning or logic

Adstar · 56-60, M

@James25 I would say either my answer is going over your head. Or maybe the LORD is blocking you from understanding..

If you cannot understand then you cannot understand.. So be it..

James25 · 61-69, M

@Adstar anyone can say what you just said it doesn't mean anything. you keep presenting logical fallacies. Never ever really presenting evidence that can be validated