You make the call!

@biandlargeny They are discussing changing the rule but because it is still a "live" ball, interference could prevent the defense from getting another "out". According to the rules, if the runner was already standing on the base when contact was made, he remains at second. In your opinion, do you think it should be a "dead ball" as soon as the IFR is put into effect? I would like your opinion.

@WizardofOz I'm thinking it's sort of a dead ball given the in fly rule. First party of the rule is the battery is automatically out, but the second party of the rule discuss the force has been removed so the runners don't have to leave the base

@biandlargeny True but in the case of an extended lead or a runner misjudging the ball, preventing the defense from cleanly fielding the ball, could cost them an out.

@WizardofOz true but the ifr eliminated that as the battery is automatically out

@biandlargeny Yes, but the ball is live. If the infielder catches it, and puts his foot on second base before the runner reaches it, it's an out. The runner can not interfere with him fielding the ball, because he can still have an appeal at second for not tagging.

@WizardofOz it's an interesting dilemma. I am leaning towards your view on it. My experience with the infield fly the runners were never that far off the base when the pop up was called an infield fly.

@biandlargeny Some runner's are overzealous lol They hear the crack of the bat and run! But, they can still be called out for not tagging up. Even on an IFR. You're right, it rarely happens in pro baseball, but there are instances that it can and ump's are usually on top of it! I'm a scout for baseball and was sent to "umpire training", as a way of seeing how smart prospects are of the rules, and I have to say, I am impressed with the rules I never knew existed! And the training umpires go through.

@WizardofOz I was really into umpiring and wanted to go to the MLBs umpire development camp in florida 35 years ago. If you make it through that program you could be assigned to any of the profeessional leagues

@biandlargeny I wouldn't want the job. I was sent just to learn rules and certain violations, so I can see how aware future prospects are for the team I represent. It's a huge thing now! Player's should know the rules! As well as managers. I know you were an umpire and the other day they were discussing how little league and highschool umps are in demand, mainly because of the unnecessary abuse they take. I played baseball my whole life and never respected umps more than I do now! But, I will say, I'm glad Angel Hernandez and Joe West retired! They hated my Milwaukee Brewers! Lol

@WizardofOz LOL Angel Hernandez hated the strike zone. he was horrible. There are many many rules the fans and players never heard of. I enjoyed umpiring. I started in my teens. Its really not bad, Most coaches and players are decent. As long as your calls are consistent and you are loud. they wont bother arguing.

@biandlargeny YES! They mentioned that! lol teams will respect you if you are consistent! You give him a big strike zone, then my pitcher gets one! I think you were the one saying that catcher's are usually the most "rule conscious" people on the field? I've learned that too! And they can develop a special rapport with an umpire. It is really cool learning!

@WizardofOz absolutely catchers are your best friends on the field. Especially the good ones, they stop bad pitches from hitting you.

You can have a tight zone too but let the catcher know where you are calling the zone so they know in advance. In little league the zone is a bit bigger becauseyou want the hitters to swing.