Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

I Am An Atheist

I was raised as a Christian but thankfully not that strictly. We would go to church occasionally but I think it was my doing that we stopped going. I would ask the pastor all sorts of sticky questions that he really couldn't answer, I was just a bit too logical to be a believer.

At the age of 10 my mother told me in all seriousness that women had 1 more rib than men. She never told me where she got that idea from but I guessed it was the story of Eve being made from one of Adam's ribs. That made me very suspicious so I spent the next few lunchtimes at school in the library doing some research on it.

Of course, there is no difference between the male and female body in structure, just how hormones make the body develop.

Finding that she was wrong about that it got me wondering what else she had wrong. I think it was the idea of Noah's Ark that I could just never justify to myself.

At the age of 11 or 12 the teacher was telling us the story of Noah's Ark and being the inquisitive lad that I was, I was asking many questions. It was that day I stood up in class and declared I didn't believe in the tales in the bible ans consequently Christianity.

Australia isn't a "religious or bust" country, so my declaration didn't cause any waves. It was certainly a weight off my chest and I'm pretty sure I gave courage to a few others in the class to admit they were atheists too.

I feel so very sorry for believers being indoctrinated into their particular religion before the age of reason, they don't have a choice. I was fortunate enough to not be in a strictly religious family and to reason my way out of religion before it became who I was. Others in different circumstances just don't have a chance.

It's not even their parent's fault either, they too were indoctrinated as children.

Thankfully the internet has given people the resources to question their faith and actually get answers. I truly believe the death of religion is mere generations away. What will replace it is something I don't know, but I think I'll see it in my lifetime.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
newjaninev2 · 56-60, F
HippyJoe, what is the basis for your claim that “everything does not evolve from nothing”? (as an aside, in what sense are you using the word ‘evolve’... do you mean ‘arise’?)

Likewise, what is the basis for your claims that “order does not arise from chaos” and that “life does not come from nonliving”? (I assume that you have some or other basis for making such claims, other than convenience).

“The fact is you have no idea what 'God' is”
The fact is… nor do you.
Before you go making a series of unsupported claims about its characteristics, you first need to establish its existence. In fact, you need to establish that there’s a compelling necessity to even postulate its existence. You have done neither of those things, so all that follows is mere conjecture and pretence. It’s not even coherent

If it were in any way valid for you to claim that your magical entity has always existed, then it would be equally valid to claim that the universe has always existed. A universe that had always existed would also be beyond time (since spacetime began with the expansion of the universe).
Any claim that the universe has always existed, besides being equally (in)valid, also carries the advantage of being simpler, since it removes the necessity to postulate the existence of a ‘middle-man’. After all, if the universe has always existed, then what need of a creator for that universe?

You claim omniscience and omnipotence for your magical entity, yet it would not even be able to change its mind. When we change our minds, we surprise ourselves, but it would already know that it was going to change its mind, so where’s the surprise? If it did in fact surprise itself, then omniscience is gone. Hmm… apparently self-awareness also needs to go.

“Purposelessness does not beget purpose”. Where does this ‘purpose’ come from? Does it come from a magical entity that has not been shown to exist? There is no compelling necessity to even postulate its existence, yet you now claim that it has a purpose. Aren’t you rather getting ahead of yourself there?

"Non living matter does not beget life"
Again you make an unsupported claim... this time about abiogenesis.
Would you like to discuss abiogenesis in more detail? I'm happy to do so.
As always, perhaps we should begin with definitions.
I would propose defining 'life' as 'a self-sustaining chemical system that is capable of Darwinian evolution', but perhaps you have an alternative definition on which we can base our discussion?
Let me know.