Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

I Like to Read

Just finished a book about the Crusades by British-French writer Hilaire Belloc.

Belloc was a fervent Catholic. Someone who did not hesitate to write 'Europe is the Faith, and the Faith is Europe'. His vision of history is, of course, Catholic. So is his vision of the Crusades. He is honest from the beginning declaring that he is writing from one side of the trenchline (which happens to be mine too). If you see this a flaw, which is understandable, better go somewhere else. There are hundreds of books about this matter written from perspectives very different from his.

His Catholic view does not mean than he is complacent on the leaders of the Crusade (Belloc considers the First Crusade the only true one, so don't expect tales about Richard Lionheart here). He criticises bitterly the personal ambitions of some chiefs, more interested in gaining lands and building their own feuds than in the conquer of the Holy Places of Christianity. He is also very critical on the lack of decision of the Byzantine Emperors of the time to support more openly the Christian army with larger troops.

But the issue that interests Belloc the most is the fact that more than 100.000 people were moved by an ideal and by the Faith. Many of them were not even armed. Few of them were knights, others were soldiers, many were just pilgrims. Despite the weaknesses of human spirit, too often fooled by material wealth, a common faith joined them.
twistermind · 51-55, F
I'm scared of masses being driven by ideals. The emotions take the control and blind us. We stop being humans and only live and breath for an idea and forget what and who is lost along the way.
Thus, I have my strong doubts about if the ones who wake up these emotions on the masses, are even convinced of these ideals or they have their own deep purposes.

I will never forget a quote "kill your idols". For me, it means, don't hear the one who wants to draw your path, the one who tells you how to live your life. Which your goals must be. What is waiting for you beyond death. They don't know it.
Abrienda · 26-30, F
AHHHHHHHHHH! My God are you are kidding!!!!!!!!!!!1


"What ever happens, we have got,
the Maxim gun, and they have not"!

I LOVE Belloc! Moreover he reminds us that when Moslems cry about the Crusades these lands were all Christian for centuries before conquered by Islam. Thus these can just as easily be considered liberated, not conquered lands...as was Southern Spain something my ancestors took part ~ the "Reconquista".

But of course there is much, much more to him and his writings...one of the great minds of Western civilization.
JustNik · 51-55, F
That sounds interesting. Sometimes a singular perspective is more meaningful than the ones who try to cover many at once having no passion for any.
Cierzo · M
Agree with you. When the author is honest and warns from the beginning that his vision is sided, you cannot criticise him for this reason. And there is a passion about the matter lacking in the works trying to cover different perspectives.
SW-User
Maybe their motives where different but in fact it was as manipulative as modern society is as well, there a lot of singularities with that period and things what happen now.

 
Post Comment