Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

If Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin Orders the IRS to Not Furnish Congress With Trump's Tax Returns, the Remedy Should Be...

Poll - Total Votes: 6
Congress Should Hold Mnuchin In Contempt of Congress and Order His Arrest
Congress Should Impeach Mnuchin for Violating the Law
Show Results
You can only vote on one answer.
Seems like contempt, but Congress isn't set up to enforce contempt or arrest anyone without the DOJ helping and my guess is, it wouldn't.

Mnuchin's on the hot seat, and I expect Trump and\or White House Counsel and\or Barr might try to take the heat off and file suit to give him cover for the contempt, and avoid or at least put off impeachment threats.
beckyromero · 36-40, F
@MistyCee

Actually, the sergeant at arms can make the arrrest.

In the 1930s a former Assistant Secretary of Commerce was arrested and jailed for 10 days after a trial in the Senate. The U.S. Supreme Court upheld the sentence.

Impeachment would be more practical and a trial would hit Mnuchin where it hurts, in his pocketbook, because he could face prosecution as well if convicted.

More likely, the Democrats will simply fight this in the Courts.
@beckyromero Wow. I just read about McCracken. That's pretty bizarre.

I guess they can take the Senate's temperature on impeachment, but it seems unlikely, so it seems like it ought to end up in court, but im not exactly sure which way it might get there if the DOJ refuses to prosecute.

Maybe the House could file a mandamus suit against Mnuchin?
abe182 · 46-50, M
By law he cannot.
windinhishair · 61-69, M
@abe182 Anyone who becomes potus is an idiot? Or is he an idiot if his tax returns are provided? Either way, he has to do it by law. He can't opt out because he's afraid someone will discover tax fraud.
abe182 · 46-50, M
@windinhishair 🤦‍♂️
Anyone who forces the viewing of the tax returns of the president of the United States without his consent, is an idiot.

And what are they hoping to find?
windinhishair · 61-69, M
@abe182 They are likely to find tax fraud, for starters. The purpose would be to find out where Trump has financial interests, because his refusal to put his assets in a trust creates conflicts of interest in his dealings with other nations. We need to know where those conflicts are, to serve the interests of the nation. Trump clearly serves only his own interests.
he is not obligated to.
booboo · M
[image deleted]
abe182 · 46-50, M
@booboo this exactly.
wouldn’t both of those end up with his arrest
beckyromero · 36-40, F
@MysteriousAura

With impeachment only if he is prosecuted after being convicted.
StevetheSleeve · 31-35, M
Option 3 could be to just let it go.

 
Post Comment