Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Do you think the value of a life between a human and an animal is the same? If you had to choose between saving a human vs an animal...

Which would you choose?
LoveChild · 26-30, F
Sorry Mr. Trump. I like my dog Midas better.
Nebula · 41-45, F
Is the animal endangered?
SW-User
It depends. We typically think of the value of life in terms of personhood, and personhood has been debated about for millennia. Is a brain-dead vegetable of a person worth the same as a loving, intelligent pet dog? What if it's your dog? Or if it was someone close to you that was comatose? Think about the abortion debate too.

As for me, I think personhood operates on a subjective scale. People we know are more important to us than strangers, adults are worth more to us than fetuses, etc. So honestly, the answer depends on which human and which animal we're talking about.
Ynotisay · M
I do think humans and animals are of equal value.
All things being equal I'd save a human. Animals don't fear death. People do.
Pureblossom · 22-25, F
I suppose you would have to stay loyal to your own species first . However if the animal is endangered that causes a bit of a puzzle 😕Another thing what if the human is a terrible person who does more harm that good and the animal is sweet , innocent and will bring happiness into the world ? It seems like an easy question at first , before you look deeper into it .
[c=#BF0080]Human.[/c]
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
3venus · F
I think they are the same, but they serve different purposes in each respective life. As far as which would I choose, that's totally situationally dependent.
Redstar · 36-40, M
It depends. Is the Human someone that I know? Is the other animal nearly extinct?
Cinnamon · 31-35, F
Human, favouring my own species, the way most animals would.
lorne13 · 61-69, M
we are all animals...I'd choose an endangered species every time
SW-User
animal, humans can save themselves.
SW-User
SW-User
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
UnderTheBridge · 46-50, M
SW-User

 
Post Comment