Move to Utah

You have to break someone's heart. This is a shitty situation.

Look for a 3rd one that you love more than both those women because if you are in love with both of them you will forever question your decision. Good luck.

Love them both. Why choose?

Be honest with them.

Loving them doesn't always mean having them. So consider they may walk away. If you don't tell them, they are not loving the real you. They are in love with your mask.

First... nothing wrong or right in loving more than one... what matters is do they both love you or does only one or neither?

hope they would entertain the idea of getting along together or choose the best one that will last

You hope they are into polygamy
if not then choose only 1 or lose both

Become muslim. Then you can start a harem lol

how did this happen?

Live a double like

Marry both I guess.

Are you up to it