Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Is the draw of big government vs small government basically an appeal to optimism vs pessimism on human nature?

The big government people point to people suffering and say we obviously need government rules to help them. They are optimistic that good, wise leaders will use that power for the good of the public.

The small government people point to government overreach and say giving them any more power than absolutely necessary is dangerous. They are pessimistic that the government will always be good and expects it will be corruptible eventually.

Top | Newest First | Oldest First

hunkalove · 61-69, M

Government, big or small, is a necessary evil. I don't think anyone likes big government except the people who work there.

SW-User

@hunkalove They can create red tape which is certainly frustrating. But I have found most governments who want to be 'small' do so by neglecting social programs that need to happen.

hunkalove · 61-69, M

@SW-User I don't think it has to be like that. Big government wastes money on itself.

SW-User

Likely simplistic, but the virtues in nature in what they offer could be considered that way. I try to remain hopeful, and vastly I do not understand people who can't see private companies need profit and only governments can run deficits to help people. Which is essentially redistribution of wealth to help those less off.

I'm Canadian... will give you a political/social idea of me.

Xuan12 · 31-35, M

Government is influenced by many factors. One being the amount of effort it takes to maintain order. Another being the ambition and penetration of those seeking wealth or power.

Add a comment...