Is this syncretism? [Spirituality & Religion]

Okay, so I know this probably won't get a lot of responses, but I am currently working on a presentation for my Humanities class. I was curious if the pagan rituals surrounding Christmas could be considered syncretism? (The reconciliation of different rites and practices into a single philosophy or religion)

My textbook uses this example: How better to convert pagan peoples than to present your religious program in their own terms? After all, the Greek god Dionysus had, like Christ, promised human immortality in the manner of the grapevine itself, which appears to die each fall only to be reborn in the spring. Just as Christians had prefigurings of Christ in the Hebrew Bible, it was possible to argue that Dionysus was a pagan type of Christ.

So, could the fact that most of the symbols used in Christmas come from pagan holidays count as an example of syncretism? PLEASE HELP!

Top | Newest First | Oldest First

room101 · 51-55, M

The easy answer is yes, it is an example of syncretism. However, I would be reluctant to emphasise the notion that this was used as some kind of Machiavellian way to convert people.

You mention Dionysus, there are indeed similarities between Dionysian rites and The Last Supper for example. However, there are also similarities between Dionysus and older gods from the Middle East. Also, many people point to the Ancient Roman celebrations of Saturnalia and suggest that this was co-opted as Christmas. Digging a little deeper and we find that the census which drew Biblical Joseph and Mary to Bethlehem was held during the period of Saturnalia so, of course Christ would have been born during that period.

The point is, there are many similarities between a variety of belief systems, dates of significance were significant because they celebrated some kind of religious event which then gets absorbed into the next significant event and, people will naturally embroider things that they are comfortable and familiar with into new ideas and beliefs.

marilynmichelle · F

@room101 Thank you! And I know it wasn't used necessarily in conversion, I just wanted to see if there was a correlation there.

room101 · 51-55, M

@marilynmichelle Strictly speaking, syncretism means a fusion of; doesn't successful fusion require some kind of correlation between the things being fused?

TheProphet · M

Yes it is. Everything about Christmas and many other religious beliefs are based in Paganism.

Pambi · 26-30, F

At the foundation of such an inquiry lies the basic question: Is anything in the context of Christianity original? Horus, Mithras, Krishna, Dionysus and other Pagan "Gods" all share similar characteristics.

marilynmichelle · F

@Pambi I mean, I understand what you're asking, but I just need to know if the symbols such as the Christmas tree, Yule Log, etc could be classified as syncretism as they originated from pagan tradition.

Pambi · 26-30, F

@marilynmichelle Might be a challenge to make such a connection. The Vikings as a reach, thought that evergreens were the special plant of the sun god, Balder.

Germany is actually credited with starting the Christmas tree tradition. In the 16th century when devout Christians brought decorated trees into their homes.

marilynmichelle · F

@Pambi Ah, okay. Thank you. I'll look into that more!

ladycae · 100+, F

this is perhaps not the best place to ask this. here you have a real clash of cultures,

walabby · 61-69, M

My vote, for what it's worth would be yes...

Add a comment...