Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Need opinion. W ould you buy this?

My sister h a s debilitating neuropathy in her feet.She can' b arely walk. There is a massager for neuropathic feet that sends electrical signals up the feet to produce blood flow..thus bringing oxygen to the dying nerves. This particular product is 100 bucks and got MANY good reviews on FB. However on another page on FB several people said do not buy...it breaks down and they don't refund as they said.
There are other companies that Sell it but for just 50 bucks. They also had a mix of good reviews but again many said it also broke in a month. My gut is to not buy it a at all because of the fact it doesn't function after a certain time. But my sister is DESPERATE for anything and there were many many positive reviews for the $100 one...(its just that the same type product costs 50 elsewhere). I'm really torn. She is in severe torture . On a positive note we are settling up a Gofund soon so she can try Laser light therapy soon in a doctor's office. But that may be a couple weeks away or more. Would you order product anyways?
Massageman · 70-79, M
Generally speaking, a "massager' (as in a mechanical massaging unit) will not send electrical impulses up the leg. What it MIGHT do is move the muscles, which, in turn, creates an afferent nerve impulse sent to the CNS. A TENS UNIT- which are becoming very popular- would be more in keeping with what is needed to offset the debilitating nerves impulses, and some basic ones are available for under $100. Another possibility would INTERFERENTIAL UNIT nerve treatment in the docs' office, although these units are also available to PT's as well. With these, two mild electrical impulses are sent, via electrodes, through the problem area. If the patient feels a simple "wave like" action- with the pulse building and receding, building and receding, the pulses are in sync. The other way to use the unit is to have the pulses deliberately OUT of SYNC, in which case the patient will feel more of a tingly sensation. The use of either function of the unit needs to be reviewed with the doc before the treatment to provide more of the desired outcome and relief, and to eliminate the possibility of using the Tx that might worsen the pain rather than help relieve it. I do wish you well in your search, and I hope these explanations help.
SnailTeeth · 36-40
I don't see why you wouldn't.

I'd do some more shopping first though, check the best reviews, durability, deals, warranties, common issues.

The more relief they get in their feet, the more active they can be, which will hopefully promote more blood flow.

Do they have compression socks?
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@SnailTeeth Ty snail. They all apparently stop working after a month or two. With no refund. But I guess we could try and hope for the best since there were many good reviews too. She is going to ask her doctor for compression socks.
SnailTeeth · 36-40
@Coralmist You can even just get some compression socks off Amazon for now, and get prescription ones later. The non-prescription ones probably won't be as tight as the prescription ones. Prescription compression socks are often tighter.
The socks would probably bring a lot of relief. Maybe you could start there, and then assess the need for another machine.
Be sure to remove them before bed.
TakeCare87 · 36-40, M
If I had the money I'd just buy the 100 dollar machine to ease her anxiety. So what if it breaks down, so long as it does not cause her any further harm and calms her down for the duration that it remains working, I'd do that for her.
ninalanyon · 61-69, T
There is a BBC programme that reported on TENS machines and circulation boosters. Perhaps it might be useful
Released On: 14 Mar 2024

Greg's getting electric for this one, as he tries out a tens machine. Tens (transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation) is a type of pain relief which uses a mild electrical current. They're marketed at all types of pain - but do they work? The NHS isn't convinced yet. Listener Patrick is one of many who have asked about these devices, so we got in touch with a a professor who's studied them for 40 years. Also - another type of electrotherapy is a circulation booster. These circular devices claim to be able to help sore legs by activating the muscles. On behalf of listener Rick, Greg finds out what the evidence is for their effectiveness.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001x538
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@ninalanyon from the description, tens is very different. But tens do have fda approval.
ninalanyon · 61-69, T
@samueltyler2 TENS is not what @Coralmist's sister needs as far as I can tell. TENS might well be approved by the FDA but it is a pain relief device rather than a circulation booster. The BBC programme asked experts and it was pointed out that none of these devices are approved of by NICE (National Institute of Health and Care Excellence) but that this does not necessarily mean that they are useless. Rather it means that in a clinical setting that NICE does not regard them as sufficiently cost effective when compared with other therapies (such as supervised exercise in the case of the circulation booster).

Finding someone who already has such a machine and borrowing it was suggested at the end of the programme so as to find out if it helps before spending a lot of money.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@ninalanyon yrs, I said that about tens.
Massageman · 70-79, M
A mechanical "massager" cannot "send an electrical signal up the feet". What it CAN do is to indirectly coax the body to create a signal, but this is in no way a guarantee since there is a Dx of neuropathy in both feet. Direct ES (electrical stimulation) CAN be used as part of a multiple-discipline TX of the condition, including manual massage from a therapist, but must be done using the correct equipment. As a licensed, certified MT for 30+ years, I wouldn't buy, condone the use of or suggest such a unit to create electrical impulses, only for passive movement of the involved musculature.
If affordability is not in question, I'd opt for acupuncture/ acupressure therapy because the neuropathy is not just in her feet, it's just that her feet are getting the brunt of it. She needs someone who understands meridians and activates those regularly.
ronisme1 · 61-69, M
Costco was selling one. I was hurting that day and tried it. It worked however i think it just overwhelms the nerve endings into being numb. It was over $200.00. M
ronisme1 · 61-69, M
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@ronisme1 Have you found any treatment that helps? My sister feet are so numb she may need nerve regeneration surgery. She is going to try Laser therapy soon.
ronisme1 · 61-69, M
@Coralmist Tylenol and or gabapentin and avoid all sugar
Teslin · M
I can't see what you are looking to purchase. But I have a Tens Unit that sounds like it does something similar. My unit was only $25. You do have to purchase additional pads, but I am able to use mine multiple times before I replace them.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
Is it FDA approved for use? The rules for equipment is more lax than medication, if unapproved, don't waste your money, and potentially risk damage to her.
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@samueltyler2 It does say FDA approved.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@Coralmist then it may be worth the investment.
WandererTony · 56-60, M
I feel you should buy the hundred bucks one. Firstly, I believe the system works Hence, secondly, I feel the cheaper one is an imitation where is risk of losing your money
Jenny1234 · 51-55, F
I would order it anyways
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@Jenny1234 we got one that was Inexpensive thank goodness..fingers crossed
Jenny1234 · 51-55, F
@Coralmist I hope it arrives soon. Let us know how she does with it. Fingers crossed
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@Jenny1234 Ty Jenny🌹

 
Post Comment