Why Americans (ok, some) think Catholics aren't Christians? [Spirituality & Religion]
They're the very pillar of Christianity.
Top | Newest First | Oldest First
Angelly · F
I can share my experience. I was raised in a very devout Catholic family(I am non-religious). The elders always refer to themselves as CATHOLICS,not Christians. If any family member is not baptized or married in the Catholic Church, is not "really" married. If you belong to a Christian Church, then you are not a follower of the "true" religion. I think that way of thinking is common amongst congregates😖
SW-User
Oh, I see. From my experience being Catholic is like being a New-Yorker, you're still American(=Christian)
Angelly · F
Yeah, but the elders in my family don't make that correlation😒
InOtterWords · F
View 23 more replies »
No. You missed my point completely. @MrMarcus:
@MrMarcus: Jesus wasn't created by God. Where are you getting all this? The Trinity has [b]always[/b] existed. Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. Jesus wasn't created by anyone. The Bible says Hes always existed. Our minds can't understand that.
SW-User
@GraceFromEP: I'm not stating what I personally believe in, I'm stating what JW's believe.
Here. These are their explanations on the topic
https://www.jw.org/en/bible-teachings/questions/jesus-gods-son/#?insight[search_id]=e56cda75-5cd2-43fb-9249-fe602dcb5ee9&insight[search_result_index]=2
Here. These are their explanations on the topic
https://www.jw.org/en/bible-teachings/questions/jesus-gods-son/#?insight[search_id]=e56cda75-5cd2-43fb-9249-fe602dcb5ee9&insight[search_result_index]=2
The Roman's politicized the early Christian church and mixed in paganism with early Christianity thus making it more palpable for the local constituency. This is how the 'Catholic church' came about. Catholicism is nothing like early Christianity, but it 'is' a sect of Christianity. Fitting for a religion with 100 thousands sects.
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
Explain why they are the very pillar of Christianity, over others.
SW-User
Just because they represent most of Christians population in the world, and they have been the first Christian Church to ever exist, or at least that we know of.
LadyWioness · 56-60, F
SW-User
because many people don't really bother to get to the bottom of historical facts, what words really mean, figuring out what the group they consider themselves part of really think, nor even what the group they consider to be outsiders thinks. a consequence of oversimplification, I think.
Mondayschild · F
😂
Gauntlets28 · 26-30, M
bijouxbroussard · F
Because some people who call themselves "Christians" are ignorant. If there's a way to exclude somebody they're going to find it. If you don't worship in exactly the same way they do, you're wrong. The last time I wasted arguing with someone who said that, I asked them if they understood from whence Protestantism came.
"Of course," she said, "our church is Protestant."
"Sooo," I continued, "Your church was established in [b]protest[/b] against whom ?"
"Against the Catholics, I guess," she admitted.
"Wouldn't that suggest that the Catholic church existed first ?" I pressed.
[b](crickets)[/b]
"Of course," she said, "our church is Protestant."
"Sooo," I continued, "Your church was established in [b]protest[/b] against whom ?"
"Against the Catholics, I guess," she admitted.
"Wouldn't that suggest that the Catholic church existed first ?" I pressed.
[b](crickets)[/b]
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
SimplyTracie · 26-30, F
Hah! Was that comment deleted or did he block me? I don't see it any longer. 🤔
SW-User
@SimplyTracie: he deleted it
SimplyTracie · 26-30, F