Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Should every biological parent have the right to raise a child?

Poll - Total Votes: 4
No, the child's safety is of the upmost importance.
Yes, Parental rights in this country have already been eroded.
Show Results
You can only vote on one answer.
Before you adopt or foster a child, most agencies are required to perform background checks, pre-home checks, mental health assessments, post adoption visits, etc. However, those probes don't apply to biological parents. Should the government also perform background checks and parent readiness assessments on biological parents? Or do you feel it would violate parental rights?
Eugenics much?

Or is this just foreplay for other social fantasies?
@CopperCicada I didn't' say I supported it. I was only asking a question. That's not exactly Eugenics. Eugenics involves selecting which children should be born based on the parents' characteristics - a form of selective breeding. What I'm talking about is selective parenting. But again, I didn't say I support those arrangements.
SW-User
Those checks don't apply because a.) the children are their natural children, and b.) it is less natural for someone to "love" a child who isn't their own.

When you conceive a child, it's natural for you and the rest of your family to really form a love for that child. That love starts before the birth, which is why you make adjustments to your life during pregnancy, have prenatal checks, buy clothes/other essentials, toys for your baby, etc. You have an innate bond with your child, which is generally a "given". People who are looking to foster or adopt don't have any preexisting relationship, connection or bond with the child and that is mostly why they are subject to checks.

Placing children with people who aren't biological relatives is a *very* serious decision, and one that I think should only happen if parents and other family members lack the willingness to look after the child, or are physically abusive.

If we introduced checks for parents, it would create a system where people are held to unfair standards (e.g, what if the parents are religious and get persecuted for that?) and intervention where it is not necessary.

Personally, I'm very wary of involvement from the state so I would be concerned for people if this was introduced. Beyond the obvious uses we have for government, we shouldn't have that much faith in them...the reality is that they would likely abuse a system like this.

Note: women have midwives in pregnancy, and they can usually tell whether the woman and her partner are up to the task of caring for the child.
JimboSaturn · 51-55, M
Oh man that would be a "Karen's" dream job to be on the committee to decide correct parental behavior 😋
And I did adopt and had to go through all the process
Getting pregnant is a natural human function. Besides, do you gaurantee they won't get pregnant by accident. You can't.
@Spoiledbrat Chastity belt
JimboSaturn · 51-55, M
Total invasion of parents rights regardless of how shitty some parents are lol
SW-User
I believe it wouldn't be possible to asses readiness of all parents but as soon as there is any mistreatment or abuse happening biological parents should lose the right to parent.

 
Post Comment