What's the first love song that ever gave you the warm and fuzzies?

"Bleeding Love" by Leona Lewis. That song came out on the heels of my first real breakup.

I used to think about my crush and listen to Madonna crazy for you.

Kiss - Forever (I heard "Beth" late, don't judge)

Good choice!

Gino Vannelli "Living Inside Myself"

Skylark "Wildflower" gets Honorable Mention.