Top | Newest First | Oldest First
Dumbledore. Easily.
Gandalf's real power is in his ability to turn the tides of history through action.
He does have some of what we would consider magic but it's mostly just fire.
Dumbledore on the other hand can transmute matter, conjure energy and objects and ensnare the senses.
He could do anything from a killing curse to turning Gandalf's fire into a snake that turns and bites him.
I like Gandalf but there's no contest here.
Fucking Ginny Weasley could beat Gandalf.
Gandalf's real power is in his ability to turn the tides of history through action.
He does have some of what we would consider magic but it's mostly just fire.
Dumbledore on the other hand can transmute matter, conjure energy and objects and ensnare the senses.
He could do anything from a killing curse to turning Gandalf's fire into a snake that turns and bites him.
I like Gandalf but there's no contest here.
Fucking Ginny Weasley could beat Gandalf.
View 1 more replies »
@ViciDraco
There's nothing in the movies, the trilogy or the silmarillion that suggests Gandalf could stand up to the power that even an average adult wizard in harry potter has, much less the greatest wizard of a generation.
So he could block a spell? Neat. They teach that in what, first year at hogwarts? Second year maybe?
The magic in lord of the rings is crude and unrefined compared to the sorts of spells in the harry potter universe.
There's nothing in the movies, the trilogy or the silmarillion that suggests Gandalf could stand up to the power that even an average adult wizard in harry potter has, much less the greatest wizard of a generation.
So he could block a spell? Neat. They teach that in what, first year at hogwarts? Second year maybe?
The magic in lord of the rings is crude and unrefined compared to the sorts of spells in the harry potter universe.
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
EmeraldOdinelle · 22-25, F
Gandalf obviously
Sharky86 · 36-40, M
Who da hell is DUMBguy?
Gandalf hands down
Gandalf hands down
coffeedimplez · 26-30, F
@Sharky86 😧
Experienced33 · M
Dumbledore...Richard Harris was the best...
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
Quizzical · 46-50, M
Gandalf. No contest