Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Mental illness and religion.

Is it time society viewed religious beliefs as a mental illness?
How would society benefit if it couldn't control billions of people with this nonsensical belief?
Why dont you just leave others beliefs alone? It's more mentally unstable to be so preoccupied with other people values and beliefs than their beliefs themselves.
Live your own life and understand what mental illness really is before you start trying to label others with it lol
JBird · F
@hippyjoe1955 too funny that you call me mentally unstable for denying the 'reality' when you can't even prove it's real. 😂 Your thoughts are nothing more of result of too many drugs and lack of logical thinking. Why should anyone listen to you?
Entwistle · 56-60, M
@hippyjoe1955 You said "Even more mentally ill" so you do believe belief in a god is a mental illness?
hippyjoe1955 · 61-69, M
@Entwistle Try reading my comment in context. You do know what context is don't you? I hope I don't have to explain it to you.
HeteroDox · 36-40, F
Indoctrination. Like any learned behaviour, you are programmed from a young age to believe what your elders do and told you will burn for eternity if you dont. The problem the indoctrinated, they cant not intrude onto other people and force their belief, no matter how ridiculous.

It can be deprogrammed IF they choose, but it has to be choice.
SW-User
@HeteroDox You? Who's you? You can't speak for other people. You are making grand assumptions. You didn't live anyone's life but your own so you can't make those kind of sweeping statements with any validity. I believe in God and I was never told that or raised that way.
HeteroDox · 36-40, F
@SW-User I speak sociologically. If you take it personally, that's your issue.
Entwistle · 56-60, M
Imagine you are on the psychiatrists couch and she asks you what's bothering you?
You reply "Nothing,all is well as an invisible being is in control of my life!(although he lets billions of people suffer)..would the psychiatrist judge you sane or insane?
@Entwistle I don't think a psychiatrist would [i]touch[/i] that.
Magenta · F
@Entwistle Speaking of control. Sounds like someone is being controlled by another person sitting in a chair with a piece of paper on the wall...
Miram · 31-35, F
Clinically speaking, it does not fit the criteria which define what a mental illness is.

I would be content with religions being[c=#BF0000] [b]truly[/b][/c] open to moral progress, instead of being static.
Entwistle · 56-60, M
@Miram How are religions clinically defined?
No religion is static.
Miram · 31-35, F
@Entwistle

Defining religion isn't within the scope of psychiatry. I said being religious doesn't fit the criteria for a mental illness diagnosis.

[quote]No religion is static.[/quote]

There are many religious laws related to religious morality that haven't changed since centuries which is my point.
It wouldn't benefit. It is not the fault of religion as much as of bad people who use it for control. It would shift to other ideologies, such as politics. There are always the greedy and ambitious who convince others to follow them and weak who need to be led. That would not change, it would only mutate.

People who think others should be labeled insane because they disagree scare me at least as much as bad religious leaders.
Entwistle · 56-60, M
@Mamapolo2016 Okay. I have a friend called Eric,i saw him walk on water and raise the dead..would a psychiatrist deem me insane for saying and believing that? What if I told him my friend was a ghost called Jesus?
@Entwistle Probably a psychiatrist would. I have a friend who is violently opposed to the right of people to wear orange, even if they do nothing else illegal. She wants them all put in an insane asylum. She lobbies for this every chance she gets. Is she entirely sane?
Entwistle · 56-60, M
@Mamapolo2016 No she isn't entirely sane.
Magenta · F
Wow, that's pretty radical. One could say the same thing about other "beliefs" and accepted far fetched "theories"..
Entwistle · 56-60, M
@Magenta Indeed they could. Care to give an example?
Some religious people [b]do[/b] seem almost mentally ill; they can't (or perhaps they just choose not to) discuss [b]any[/b] topic without framing it in a religious reference. 😳
Virgo79 · 61-69, M
Everytime I see a post like this makes me blieve even more the bible may be right.
Virgo79 · 61-69, M
@JBird well any stable person knows it's all happened, just as condemning religion, as you are.
It's not that I support any of that.
Conversation over.
JBird · F
@Virgo79 [quote]
it's all happened
[/quote]
If you are stable person and believe everything in the Bible happened, explain how did Adam and Eve populated the world with just two of them? I mean they had two sons with one of them died, so how was it possible?

Then in the Noah's ark, how did he managed to fit million species of animals from all over the world in the ark with some of them not adaptable to the environment in the ark, managed to survive the journey without animals killing each other?


How do you explain the significance of existence of heaven if only dead people can go there and as we know we can't speak to the dead?

How do you explain the validity of relating earth being flat in the Bible when it's actually round?
Virgo79 · 61-69, M
@Virgo79 as i said, conversation over🙂
JohnOinger · 41-45, M
LOL 😂 I Must Be Mentally Ill Since I Believe in God 🙄
HeteroDox · 36-40, F
@JohnOinger Non... just indoctrinated.
ancientmariner · 61-69, M
[image deleted][image deleted]
Entwistle · 56-60, M
@ancientmariner Hell and heaven are temporary mental states.
ancientmariner · 61-69, M
@Entwistle glad you think you're the authority on this subject but you are not. You are just seeking attention imo and I'm done giving you mine
Entwistle · 56-60, M
@ancientmariner Nice to know you think what I think. Bye then.
JBird · F
I always felt both religion and people can be problem. People with psychopathic traits are the ones that become extremists. Some people use religion to draw out their hate and ego on people. Religion is a perfect tool to destroy mankind, not even atomic or nuclear bomb can top that
HannahSky · F
This is ridiculous.
JBird · F
I have no problem with religion as long as they don't use it judge people, try to validate or normalise their wrong doings. It should be used as a personal means and nothing more.
hippyjoe1955 · 61-69, M
@JBird The problem with your silliness is that you assume that someone holding to their faith practices is 'hating' someone. The fact is those who are accusing Christians of hating are just as hateful if not more so. Funny how it is that only one side is calling the other for being so hateful. Kind of like Antifa in the US accusing the right wing of violence when in fact the only violence is coming from Antifa.
JBird · F
@hippyjoe1955 [quote]
problem with your silliness is that you assume that someone holding to their faith practices is 'hating' someone
[/quote]
Wow, why are you proving that you are so stupid and can't understand English despite being a native English speaker? I said I don't have a problem as long as they don't [b]use religion[/b] to hurt others. It's not hateful to talk about someone's wrong doing. Of course, you can't understand that because you're immature, stupid and egotistical. You're desparate to prove that all of Christians are innocent. But reality says another thing. Some Christians harass homosexuals, women and children because they feel they are not following their doctrines. If you were smart, you would have understand bad people are everywhere. But no, your 5 year old mentality doesn't allow that and you bully people. Insult never work. Get that into your thick head.

[quote]
Funny how it is that only one side is calling the other for being so hateful.
[/quote]
1. I didn't say all religious people are hateful.
2. You called me hateful first, so your statement applies to you than me. Funny how all of your claims backfires. 😂 Why are you so dumb?

[quote]
Kind of like Antifa in the US accusing the right wing of violence when in fact the only violence is coming from Antifa.
[/quote]
This applies to you again. You accused me of calling religious people hateful and proceeds to call me hateful when in reality I never generalised religious people. You are the only one here being hateful. 😂😂😂

Listen, I will you give an advice. I know you are trying so hard to show everyone that you're smart and your beliefs are right. You have to know you're being really stupid and fail to prove your God is real. That's why I said your beliefs should be yours only. Don't expect others to agree with that because they have different outlook on life or in your case, higher level of intelligence than you. 😂 Not only that you misread my comments and became aggressive for non existent reasons. I suggest you to act only after thinking logically rather than on your emotions. Good day.
Religion has its uses. While I don't particularly like it, I believe it keeps a lot of society in check, and I don't think it would be good to label it as a mental illness and discourage belief in it.
Entwistle · 56-60, M
@boklenholley7 It certainly does keep a lot of people in check.
Ladyred · 46-50, F
Control is the issue, isn't it? Who ultimately is in control? Is there a difference between religion and relationship?
The possibilities are nigh infinite without such a false burden on people's shoulders...
Entwistle · 56-60, M
Years ago I took some LSD,20 mins later the Spaghetti in my cupboard morphed into a monster and took flight!
The next night when I wasn't under the influence of LSD I read a book that told me a man walked on water and raised the dead..I believed it! So..when was I most delusional?
Success · 26-30, F
We should reserve 'mental illness' for those unable to function in society.

Call them badly misled if you must.
Success · 26-30, F
@Entwistle Are you that out of touch with reality? They go to work: same as you and I do. They raise children and cook dinner: same as you and I.
Entwistle · 56-60, M
@Success I know that.
Entwistle · 56-60, M
@Success Many mentally ill folk can and do go to work,maintain a home,have kids etc.
SW-User
This post shows deep signs of mental illness and delusion
Chickie · F
No, that makes no sense.

Leave religious people alone

 
Post Comment