Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

if the pro life men were women would they become pro choice?

if the men that are pro life were women would they become pro choice? men don't understand the kind of position women are put in when they become pregnant. I think many of them would become pro choice if they were women. they say what about the child's choice,you cant ask them so how would anyone know what their choice is. I would be more concerned with providing safe birth control. hormonal can cause cancer, condoms don't work their only good for std prevention and from what I hear it is tough for a woman without children to get a tubule ligation or cauterization.



ok follow up if people were using abortion as birth control don't you think it would be worse them having kids and not taking care of their kids and then those kids having kids? so you would be punishing them by punishing their child. many of them probably don't have the money to raise a child. if they are so irresponsible to not use birth control isnt that a bad parent because they would not teach their child to use birth control.
and I meant would more men turn pro choice not all.
SheikYerbouti · 51-55, M
Not necessarily. Lots of women are pro life.
rckt148 · 61-69, M
well my issue is using abortion as birth control
I have offered my 2 cents I wish I had never offered
many times the girl thinks that is her only option
and along comes a young know it all like I was and tell her its ok ,,it doesn't have a brain yet ,,and the standard for life when someone has a head injury ,,no brain functions ,they are only alive by artificial means ,,clinically they are dead ,,so that was my advice

Now my advice is your choice ended when you made a baby just because you are against birth control

I have seen this young lady go from a loving care giver ,to a drunkin addict who had tried to kill herself many times
they made her listen to the heart beat ,,
now thats what haunts her ,,,

My take now is if its not me ,,,I should keep my mouth shut
Unless you have worn her shoes ,,you dont know either
everyone handles things like that differently

I think both sides have valid points ,and both sides are also wrong ,,
If it is solely for birth control
they gave up that right when they created a life

I stopped my wife 3 times ,,,now she is happy I did
Our greatest joy is our 3 kids and 6 grandkids ,,I also have a son from another woman ,,we planned him to the day he was born ,,my birthday

My wifes reasons was she did not want a baby messing up her perfect body ,,it didn't
I did when I hit a tree drinking and driving
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
SW-User
if men could get pregnant abortions would never have been an issue in the first place
SW-User
To me it seems that the majority of pro life people is afraid that allowing abortion will lead to it being used as an alternative to contraception. That seems highly unlikely though. If we could get that misunderstanding out of the way, most people would probably be on the same page.
SW-User
@rckt148 Proper sex education is definitely the most important way to prevent pregnancies in the first place. And by "proper" I mean explaining all options, not just telling teenagers not to have sex before marriage. You have a point about STDs too, but that deserves it's own thread. It doesn't affect abortion in any way, so I'm not going to discuss that here.
SW-User
@BryanSunshine I'm pleasantly surprised you actually gave me a source. In many discussions about any topic, that seems too much to ask. Please give me some time to read through it and write a reply to actually address it, but thank you very much for actually challenging me with facts to back up your point.
SW-User
@BryanSunshine The circumstances of getting pregnant are essential, so I personally categorize the reasons for abortion as follows:
- Valid: not having a choice to use contraception, or planning a healthy pregnancy and it turning out differently.
- Possibly invalid: valid if contraceptives were used properly but failed to be effective regardless, invalid if the pregnancy was due to negligence.

Now let's categorize all given reasons into these two options:

[b]Valid[/b]
<0.5% Victim of rape
3%Fetal health problems
4%Physical health problems
Total: 7%

[b]Possibly invalid[/b]
4%Would interfere with education or career
7%Not mature enough to raise a child
8%Don't want to be a single mother
19%Done having children
23%Can't afford a baby
25%Not ready for a child
Total: 86%

I left out the "other" 6% because I can't judge those. It seem like you are correct that the majority of abortions by far is performed for invalid or questionably reasons...

But your source also states that "9 in 10 women at risk of unintended pregnancy are using a contraceptive method". If you agree with my categorization, that means only 1 in 10 of possibly invalid reasons actually are and 9 out of 10 are instead valid. Applying that factor means 84% of abortions have a valid reason and only 9% have invalid motives.

I agree that 9% of abortions being performed for invalid reasons is a LOT. However, 84% being performed for valid reasons is a strong point to support the option, especially as it considers a choice and not a forced measure depending on the category.

One final note: these statistics were supplied by a website with it's first main menu item being "the case against abortion". If the numbers are biased, it would definitely be towards the pro-life movement and yet they point to pro-choice. I don't think we even need to question the objectivity here, nor consider what numbers that are proven to be objective or biased towards the pro-choice movement instead will show.
xixgun · M
Allow me to respond to your post, with a question.
How do you explain pro life women?
@xixgun why do i need to explain that? at least they know what its like to be able to have a kid.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
@ISpeakTheTruth its not the discomfort of pregnancy women dont like its all the other things that come along with it,like raising a baby, thats my point men dont get that, they wont understand unless it happens to them.
DunDunDun · 22-25, F
Clearly not all of them because there are women who are against abortion but a lot of them would because they'd actually have to consider what it's like to get pregnant and to take care of a child, something most of them probably haven't thought about at all.
DunDunDun · 22-25, F
@rckt148 Okay good for you but I was speaking in general and I made that very clear.
@BryanSunshine Again I specifically said that I'm not talking about all men.
BryanSunshine · 51-55, M
Sorry, right. Not all. Just most. Most of us have not thought about what it's like to take care of a child. At all.

[i]"Clearly [b]not all[/b] of them because there are women who are against abortion but [b]a lot of them[/b] would because they'd actually have to consider what it's like to get pregnant and to take care of a child, something [b]most of them[/b] probably haven't thought about [b]at all[/b]."[/i]

I amend my previous statement: Please don't lump most of us into the same bucket.
DunDunDun · 22-25, F
@BryanSunshine Well I'm not changing my mind. Like I said, most people only care about things that they can relate to. It's the same with women and men. Most people are just selfish.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
@ISpeakTheTruth I never said all women are pro choice. Im asking would more of them become pro choice. I think there are more women that are pro choice then it seems. some of them say they are pro life then go get an abortion.
SW-User
Imagine the reaction of some of those men if a room full of women continuously debated and mandated prostate health (when you can get screened, whether or not sedation should be allowed during the process, waiting periods before being allowed to treat any issues, spousal consent before having a procedure, etc.). It would feel pretty damned intrusive and pretty much like it was none of their damned business to micromanage a health issue they could never possibly experience themselves.
BryanSunshine · 51-55, M
@SW-User i see your point, but it’s far from a perfect analogy. When it comes to prostate health, there is no life of a helpless child involved.
BryanSunshine · 51-55, M
I am a man. I am both pro-life and pro-choice. I think abortion is a sad abomination, but I don’t think it should be illegal.
BryanSunshine · 51-55, M
I don't care what the connotations and so-called "official" definition of the term "pro-life" are. I am in favor of life. Period. I hate the death penalty under ANY circumstance. I hate abortion in all circumstances but a very few. I love life. I in favor of life. So, I am Pro Life.
"I don't care what the CONNOTATIONS I don't care what the CONNOTATIONS I don't care what the CONNOTATIONS I don't care what the CONNOTATIONS I don't care what the CONNOTATIONS ----------- and so-called "official" definition of the term "pro-LIFE" are. I am in favor of LIFE. Period. I hate the death penalty under ANY circumstance. I hate abortion in all circumstances but a very few. I love LIFE. I in favor of LIFE. So, I am Pro LIFE. PRO-LIFE LIFE LIFE LIFE LIFE LIFE LLLLLIIIIIFFFFFEEEEE"


Lol!
IHateMyLife0MeDie · 41-45, M
@AllChristiansAreHypocrites I rest my case :p
If more women were men, would they become pro-paternal abortion for men?
indyjoe · 56-60, M
There are many pro-lifers out there who are also women...Just thought you'd like to know.
DeWayfarer · 61-69, M
[quote]men don't understand the kind of position women are put in when they become pregnant[/quote]

Please!!! Some men do understand. Some are all for you and your rights!
DeWayfarer · 61-69, M
@IHateMyLife0MeDie I don't know if it has made my meaning clearer, yet I did add to it while your reply went through.
IHateMyLife0MeDie · 41-45, M
@DeWayfarer I don't think it's just a matter of physical pain though. We can only imagine what a woman goes through after her pregnancy. When you bring a child into this world, it's gonna take up a lot of your time, alot of your energy, compund that to whatever else is going on in your life. If you decide to have the child adopted, they're gonna be in your mind, they just don't disappear. There is a high number of abuse towards adopted children? I think these questions affect the father too, but more so the mother. The baby was inside her, then is nursed by her and was often in closer proximity to her. Of course some "fathers" just don't care and that's another factor for the woman. Oh yeah, what does it also do to the mother if the father is a rapist, what does it do to the child also if they find out their father was a monster? And so on, other things I haven't thought of.

With all due respects to what you went through. I'm sure it wasn't just the excruciating physical pain you had to deal with even.
DeWayfarer · 61-69, M
@IHateMyLife0MeDie You are right. My whole life was upturned. Everything changed! Quite literally everything. Not saying that the same as bringing a life into the world. Yet everything, from the simplest to the greatest, changed. Even all the social aspects.
BryanSunshine · 51-55, M
How do you explain women who are pro-life?
MissSimpleMind · 36-40, F
There's plenty of women who are pro-life....
firefall · 61-69, M
there's lots of 'pro-life' women. Amazingly, even when they have an abortion themselves, many will cling to this position, with an asterisk for 'except if you really need and deserve it like me, and aren't just a careless slut'.
No. If the pro-life men were not politicians getting under the table money and favors from special interests and radical churches they would be regular human beings who thought for themselves.
SW-User
yes they would
Tastyfrzz · 61-69, M
Just send them the bill for raising the kid at five weeks and see what the response is. They'd do the procedure themselves.

 
Post Comment