Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Did this teacher have every right to be harsh on these students?

Poll - Total Votes: 7
Yes she was right to do that!
No she was wrong! 😠😠
Show Results
You can only vote on one answer.
I worked with special needs children after school and one of the ladies who I became friends with, she is such a sweetheart. One next day the kids in her group who have trouble with their numbers but they know most by now. They didn't count with her. She got upset. She said harshly, "You guys need to do your work. That was disappointing. That's probably why you can barely count because you don't know your numbers!! 10 year olds that barely know their numbers! You're not going to graduate if barley know how to count! Junk!" The lead teacher and I were shocked. I was like, "Jenny! That was harsh!" The lead teacher said, "Jenny I can't believe you said that to them!" Then Jenny said, "WELL they weren't saying it! They're not even trying hard enough! What else am I suppose to say to them!"
I couldn't believe her. She never said stuff like that before. She didn't seem sorry about it. I told her after work that was so messed up. She said, "Well if they actually tried hard enough I wouldn't have to say it. I have nothing to be sorry about! Truth hurts sometimes. That's the only way students can learn. She didn't care or seem to regret what she said. She was very tried and cranky. The students looked hurt and one was about to cry.
I reported her but the boss said I need to stop gossiping and sometimes tough love is the only way for kids to work harder. She was in the right. Off you go.
lets lower the bar again so the dummies can graduate.. no wonder we import indian dentists and drs...
basilfawlty89 · 31-35, M
@TheOneyouwerewarnedabout you did see the part of it being special needs kid da right?
@basilfawlty89 and?... we should just give him a lollipop and a helmet and sit them in the corner?..
basilfawlty89 · 31-35, M
@TheOneyouwerewarnedabout no, but they actually have learning disabilities and your scenario doesn't apply in this case
SW-User
As someone who values the children's needs and happiness, I will absolutely disagree with what she had done to those special needs children. Tough love is also a way to help a person grow, but I don't think that that is tough love. Tough love is to let a person be independent on their own without any help from us. We will not help them, but we will encourage them to do it for themselves. We will do that with respect and encouragement, and strict discipline. Her words toward them are not tough love, and it was a disrespectful manner. Her behavior toward them is just the way she uses their disability to release her anger upon them. Release anger upon someone for their weaknesses is not tough love. That would make them even worse.

She has to remind herself that they are SPECIAL needs children. She treats them as if they are normal kids. If I were the boss, I would have fired her a long time ago, or reduce her salary for a year.
SW-User
@SW-User agreed, well said.
Her delivery needs work, for sure.
HannahSky · F
There's better ways to educate kids on the importance of doing the work.
abe182 · 46-50, M
She was right but not in her tact.
abe182 · 46-50, M
@MotherlessDaughter01 I agree with you. You can teach without being rude or demeaning.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
abe182 · 46-50, M
@MotherlessDaughter01 she's arrogant and pompous. Doesn't make her right.
Expecting them to learn something is reasonable. Two different things.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
xixgun · M
If she’s a sweetheart and said this, common sense would dictate that she’s having a bad day
NativeOregonian · 51-55
Shaming children isn't teaching, it's bullying.

 
Post Comment