Should birthright citizenship be revoked?

"Anchor Babies" is what that phenom is called.
It's not about revoking existing, it's about stopping more in the future. Being an immigrant myself, I think you should have to be in the country legally to qualify.

If they were born from illegal immigrants yes.

If you are an illegal immigrant giving birth here shouldn't grant the child automatic citizenship. That is not a smart policy in my opinion.

Absolutely! For new ones . The others ... if the parents are not working and only living off the system... they should all go back ! It will stop a lot of the illegal alien issues... like then becoming an anchor baby . One parent must be a citizen prior to birth for the child to be considered a citizen too, or the whole Family should be sent back . We have too many homeless / indigent Americans that deserve our help long before illegal aliens do .

Yes. Only children of citizens should get citizenship.

For those here illegally yes. Only those of citizens or with a green card.

yes. Birth tourism

Does that mean all the English, Scots, Irish, German, Poles, etc get sent back to their original home countries?

Yes because if you are born being another citizen, you’re still a citizen of that country.

yes and yes

Yes, send Baron back to Slovenia!!! And send back Trump's in-laws as examples of that despicable "chain migration" loophole.

No, they had a reason for it.

yea, fuck the constitution, right?

...what...? Are you drunk?

No

No

It should be modified the correct way. As it is the procedure is a mess for immigrant families and the US alike. Only citizens should give birth to citizens.