This post may contain Mildly Adult content.
Mildly Adult
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Exclude Illegal Aliens From Census?

The Supreme Court on Friday agreed to review a Trump administration effort to exclude illegal aliens from the 2020 census count that is used to apportion congressional seats.

In an unsigned order the justices set a Nov. 30 date to hear oral arguments from the parties.

A three-judge panel in a New York district court in September ruled that Trump’s memorandum excluding illegal aliens from congressional apportionment count was an illegal overreach of the president’s authority as delegated by Congress. The judges on that panel declared the memo, which was issued on July 21, as unlawful and subsequently blocked it from being implemented.

It boils down to this; should people in the US illegally be counted in the census for the purpose of the reapportionment of Congress members following the 2020 census.

What do you think?
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Stjerne11 · 26-30, F
Would it harm the quality of the data collected if you started excluding people?
Budwick · 70-79, M
@Stjerne11 They want to exclude illegal immigrants for the Congressional apportionment - not the total. The idea is to have apportionment based on the number of [i][b]citizens [/b][/i]being represented within a district.
@Budwick What about permanent residents with green cards?

The reason to include illegal immigrants is because in most cases, they pay taxes and use services, same as citizens do.
Budwick · 70-79, M
@LeopoldBloom Pretending illegal aliens have citizen rights fucks up any reasonable conversation.

Deport them - then the pot will be right.
@Budwick How do you deport 11 million people, dumbass? Round up any brown people who don't speak English? We still have due process in this country, at least at the moment.

Illegal aliens don't have "citizen rights," meaning they can't vote. If you don't want them to work, either, then start prosecuting the people who hire them. But don't limit to just the 4th tier drywall contractor. Go after the developers when illegal workers are found on their job sites. Locking up the head of those companies, for example, the Trump Organization, would end the problem overnight.
Platinum · M
How do you know all eleven million are illegal....@LeopoldBloom